This is not only subjective but not even definitve as I would probably change many if I did the list another day! However, it's always fun to compare with others.
BTW, where's your list Estee?

Kourtney Moon: (1,2,2)
Physical: She was really unkourtneyted
Mental: We really have no data
Social: She seemed to set herself apart from the start.

Nina Acosta: (1,1,4)
Physical: A bag of rocks.
Mental: She knew she was outside the alliance but she kept her profession a secret when it could have been her lifejacket
Social: At least, she made some members of the alliance question if they should keep her.

Matt Quinlan: (4,1,1)
Physical: Sure he had the muscles but what did he do with them?
Mental: 4 < 5
Social: The worse is that his 4 was purely imaginary as Jay and Bill were in an alliance with Troy and Jonas.

Bill Posley: (3,1,7)
Physical: He lost the men's first challenge.
Mental: Why give up immunity? Even his plan to get Colton could have waited.
Social: I think most of the tribe liked him and even the women said he was hilarious. Being hated by an ignorant a-hole

Monica Culpepper (7,7,7)
Physical: Impressive.
Mental: She had found a way to stay despite the women's alliance but fell victim to a swap.
Social: She understood that players need a mother figure. She simply was the wrong type of mother for that a-hole.

Piece of Garbage (1,1,1)
Physical: Chet-like
Mental: How was he expecting to get votes?
Social: Are you really asking?

Jonas Otsuji (6,2,6)
Physical: Since you include work in camp. In challenges he showed nothing in particular though.
Mental: He thought that guy was smart? Jonas should have stayed with his original alliance and booted his mentor. And he is the one that enabled the immunity give-away
Social: If his side had taken over, he probably gets most votes.

Michael Jefferson (7,1,3)
Physical: He did well in a few challenges and supplied fish
Mental: Stealing supplies was dumb
Social: He stayed on the periphery of the game and its alliances

Jay Byars(9,2,8)
Physical: Making fire has to count for a lot.
Mental: He could have reasoned Colton. He wasn't able to read Kim at all.
Social: Everyone liked him.

Leif Manson (5,4,4)
Physical: He was strong but it didn't do him mucg good
Mental: The players saw him as wishy-washy.
Social: Everyone liked him also but it turned against him.

Troy "Troyzan" Robertson (7,3,4)
Physical: For someone that needed immunity, he didn't score well.
Mental: Same as Jay but he did read Kim a little better.
Social: His aggresiveness killed any chance he had at getting a woman to vote with him.

Kat Edorsson (4,1,7)
Physical: Started off bad, ended up a bit better.
Mental: I would love to listen to a debate between her and BB's Jordan!
Social: Her social game kept her in at the start, it got her booted at the end!

Greg "Tarzan" Smith (2,6,5)
Physical: Maybe 20 years ago but he did work once Jonas left.
Mental: Understood how to prolong his game enough to outlast the guys
Social: It was so bad that it was good...for Survivor

Alicia Rosa (4,4,3)
Physical: Not bad.
Mental: Who was more delusional? Her or Matt? But her strategy was better as she got in on both tribes.
Social: She wasn't disliked by most of the other players.

Christina Cha (2,5,4)
Physical: Whether strategy or ineptitude, she was only good in a couple of challenges
Mental: Telling Troyzan about the split vote was smart. So was playing "nice" but she needed to be more aggressive at the end
Social: The outsider throughout the pre-merge, she only got an in because Kim needed her vote.

Chelsea Meissner (6,6,6)
Physical: Surprisingly poor in some key challenges but great with chickens!
Mental: She needed to have Kim tell her what to think
Social: She was so worried about hurting people that she didn't let them get to know her.

Sabrina Thompson (2,6,9)
Physical: It's good not to look too strong but being seen as the slacker is terrible
Mental: Kept her focus even if she was unaware at times about just how close she came to be voted out.
Social: Her strong point

Kim Spradlin (8,10,9)
Physical: The opposition wasn't great but she stole the show
Mental: That's how you play Survivor
Social: She was very well liked, everybody wanted to be on "Team-Kim"...before she booted them all! Maybe she could have told Mike that he was going.