LAST EDITED ON 07-12-06 AT 05:16 PM (EST)

I agree with some of what you say. But the contestants should have some kinda idea what the bands played that these guys came from. They ragged on a couple of the choices....I agree with them ripping on matt. As for Zayra....GNR guys comments were a little harsh because I think her version of the song was hard but in a sexy way......I guess the contestants are supposed to just use the past history as a ruler.

I do agree with you about the lifespan of Supernova. This band will be second banana to Tommy Lee....the other two guys I am not sure. I mean soon as the show stops running motley Crue is slated to coheadline with Aerosmith. This badn will most likely last one cd and be done...because Tommy will always focus his main attention to the Crue. Both of the others have long since been out of GNR and Metallica. I think the winner of this show gets more than a position with SuperNova....they get the national publicity of being in a 'supergroup'. This may also you are right effect how serious these guys are about this band....since they are likely a shortterm thing.

I agree about the song selections. But I think other than Matt's Duran Duran choice they were talking more about how one's voice and personality fit a song. On top of that they expect some creativity on rearranging the songs.

My gripes are not the same as yours. I am disappointed many of the songs are the same as last years. Geez, two weeks...two weeks Nirvana....didn't we see enough of them last season. Also, Melissa Ethridge. My other beef is that some of the contestents never really stood a chance....whether it be their style/personailty or what. Guess Burnett said these are teh best 15 singers let them adapt or be gone. Or Burnett was trying to appeal to a more main stream audience....and some are throwaways....kinda like on Burnett's other series....on the Apprentice for example some contestents never stood a chance...they are there for ratings.