From the start, I said this episode was disappointing but it isn't as bad as colin says.

Colin writes:
"We find out how the statue was broken. During a storm, a ship hit THE TOP of the statue and cracked it into pieces??? Huh? The huge stone statue cracked and the wooden boat was ok?"

The wave broke the statue.

As for Ricardo's exchange with MIB, I think the point was completely missed. When Ricardo said: "Murder is wrong. That's what brought me here" it was supposed to tell us why MIB is on the island.

Yes, it's a strange answer for someone who thinks he's dead and in hell but consider that Ricardo didn't know what to make of anything he heard. We know he was not very well-educated but deeply religious and completely confused. His true nature came out: He isn't a murderer. That's what we have to know about him. MIB is a murderer. That's what we have to know about him.

And again, I read comments saying Jacob is evil because he brings people to the island and manipulates them. I'm almost certain Jacob brings the island to people to save as many of them as possible from deadly accidents. All those he visited before, he protects as best he can from Smokey by imposing some rules.