My humble opinion...JD- I've have my issues with him, but it ultimately comes down to the fact that he above all the others seems to really want this particular gig. He's done a great job of creating professional sets the last couple of weeks, and I happen to like Pretty Vegas. I thought he did the best job tonight, and I see him as the best fit for INXS.
Marty- He seems like a nice guy, and I really want to like him. I hate the screaming though, and think the fact that he feels INXS should meet him halfway is both wrong and deceptive. He feels like he wants to front a grungier band and I just don't see it as a great fit. I'm sure he's on to great things, just not this. I wholeheartedly agree with the lack of something tonight. Trees isn't nearly as good acoustically, and I wonder why he keeps doing that when he's auditioning for a band, not another single guitarist.
Suzie- I want to root for the final female, but I don't see her as the lead singer of INXS. Tonight's performance left me cold. I think she's got a great voice, and I can see her as a soloist, but not in this genre.
MiG- I just don't think he's at JD & Marty's level. He seems like a genuinely nice guy, but I don't seeing him being vocally strong enough to do this. I think musical theatre and cheesy songs ala Whatshisname Marx. Richard!