Here's a thought.Will can't win competitions for the life of him. If Janelle had kept Will and evicted Erika, how would it have played out?
The mountain competition also depended on upper body strength. Boogie could have won it if he wasn't so angry. Either him or Janelle would have definitely won it, not Will with his broken thumb.
Say for the sake of argument, Janelle won that Mountain comp. Then it's Will against Boogie. Again, with Will's sore thumb Boogie would have won. Again, considering Will's past performances, I doubt he would have even known the order of the former Big Brother winners.
Then it's the final comp. Let's say it was definitely between Janelle and Boogie. Too close to call. Janelle was good at those type of games, be it memory or guessing. Boogie could have won either.
ButI think Janelle would have had a great chance of winning if Will had remained. Let's face facts, Boogie, Erika and Will would have evicted her if she had not won HOH that last time. But she would have had a chance to stay in the comp if Will was there.