|
|
PLEASE NOTE: The Reality TV World Message Boards are filled with desperate
attention-seekers pretending to be one big happy PG/PG13-rated family. Don't
be fooled. Trying to get everyone to agree with you is like herding cats,
but intolerance for other viewpoints is NOT welcome and respect for other
posters IS required at all times. Jump in and play, and you'll soon find out
how easy it is to fit in, but save your drama for your mama. All members are
encouraged to read the
complete guidelines.
As entertainment critic Roger
Ebert once said, "If you disagree with something I write, tell me so, argue
with me, correct me--but don't tell me to shut up. That's not the American way."
|
|
"Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion"
SnowBunny 79 desperate attention whore postings DAW Level: "Hollywood Squares Square"
|
09-20-03, 01:36 PM (EST)
|
68. "RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion" |
This discussion thread has been intriguing indeed. I have been puzzling over the possibilities for a couple of days, and here are a few thoughts I have:- Originally, I thought the dying family member suggestion was a good one because we have seen empathy/sympathy from others on the show when something like this is revealed. But, I wonder how this could get twisted around to work against the liar without the rest of the tribe knowing he had lied. It's not like the tribe would say, "Oh, he/she doesn't need a letter from home or a visit from a loved one because ..." Or, "We need to vote him/her out because of ..." - Then, I wondered if this liar portrayed himself/herself as a 9-11 victim of some sort (lost family member, lost job, etc). That seems brutal (although I would argue it's not brilliant), but again I can't see how he would live to regret it without the tribe knowing he lied. Unless, of course, his conscience gets him. - The same scenario would apply to a number of similar possibilities: war veteran with post traumatic stress, cancer victim, etc etc. I think the key lies in the regret. How does the person live to regret it if the tribe does not know they had lied? I love the Lillian is not a Scout Leader idea, but sadly that seems to have been debunked. Imagine showing up to a game like this looking the part of one to be trusted (a la Andrew's reaction when it was her word against Nicole's) only to turn out to be someone entirely different. The sexual intercourse idea might be a good one. Man claims to have had sex with woman, who is then alienated by the tribe or voted off because they worry about her alliance with him ... He might regret the lie, again because of conscience. Or, perhaps he is voted off for fear of an alliance with her. He'd certainly regret it then.
|
|
Top |
| |
Subject |
Author |
Message Date |
ID |
Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mistofleas |
09-18-03 |
|
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
KeithFan |
09-18-03 |
1 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
AZ_Leo |
09-18-03 |
2 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
FarmBoy |
09-18-03 |
3 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
VerucaSalt |
09-18-03 |
5 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mistofleas |
09-18-03 |
7 |
What about the confessionals? |
princessoftides |
09-18-03 |
11 |
RE: What about the confessionals? |
VerucaSalt |
09-18-03 |
16 |
RE: What about the confessionals? |
princessoftides |
09-18-03 |
20 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
FarmBoy |
09-18-03 |
34 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Cathy the Canadian |
09-18-03 |
23 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
rnabring |
09-18-03 |
4 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mistofleas |
09-18-03 |
6 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
smrtNsassybnkr |
09-18-03 |
8 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Amily |
09-18-03 |
13 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
smrtNsassybnkr |
09-18-03 |
24 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
FarmBoy |
09-18-03 |
35 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
tamarama |
09-18-03 |
9 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
AZ_Leo |
09-18-03 |
10 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mistofleas |
09-18-03 |
12 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
AZ_Leo |
09-18-03 |
14 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Jims02 |
09-18-03 |
15 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
smrtNsassybnkr |
09-18-03 |
17 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Rothschild |
09-18-03 |
18 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
FarmBoy |
09-18-03 |
37 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
VerucaSalt |
09-18-03 |
19 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Krautboy |
09-18-03 |
21 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
VerucaSalt |
09-18-03 |
22 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
smrtNsassybnkr |
09-18-03 |
25 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
kykate |
09-18-03 |
26 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
tamarama |
09-18-03 |
29 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
princessoftides |
09-18-03 |
27 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Krautboy |
09-18-03 |
28 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Brownroach |
09-18-03 |
30 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
VerucaSalt |
09-18-03 |
31 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Amily |
09-18-03 |
33 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mistofleas |
09-18-03 |
32 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
FarmBoy |
09-18-03 |
38 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
KeithFan |
09-20-03 |
73 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mistofleas |
09-18-03 |
36 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
tamarama |
09-18-03 |
39 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
VerucaSalt |
09-18-03 |
40 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mistofleas |
09-18-03 |
41 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
TeamJoisey |
09-20-03 |
71 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mistofleas |
09-22-03 |
88 |
How about the other way around? |
tamarama |
09-18-03 |
42 |
RE: How about the other way around? |
mistofleas |
09-18-03 |
43 |
(off topic) |
tamarama |
09-18-03 |
44 |
RE: How about the other way around? |
Brownroach |
09-18-03 |
45 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
ParkGirl |
09-18-03 |
46 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
ginger |
09-18-03 |
47 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
ginger |
09-18-03 |
48 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
silentJ |
09-18-03 |
49 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mistofleas |
09-18-03 |
50 |
Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
colleenwannabe |
09-19-03 |
51 |
RE: Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
anninvt2002 |
09-19-03 |
52 |
RE: Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
anninvt2002 |
09-19-03 |
53 |
RE: Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
Draco Malfoy |
09-19-03 |
54 |
RE: Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
Booted |
09-19-03 |
55 |
RE: Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
jkokoj |
09-19-03 |
56 |
RE: Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
rnabring |
09-19-03 |
58 |
RE: Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
FarmBoy |
09-19-03 |
57 |
RE: Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
Quali |
09-19-03 |
59 |
RE: Is Lil really a Troop Leader? |
ImNext |
09-21-03 |
76 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Brownroach |
09-19-03 |
60 |
HEY! |
princessoftides |
09-19-03 |
61 |
It IS Tijuana, but something smells... |
princessoftides |
09-19-03 |
62 |
RE: It IS Tijuana, but something sm... |
VerucaSalt |
09-19-03 |
64 |
RE: It IS Tijuana, but something sm... |
tamarama |
09-19-03 |
66 |
RE: HEY! |
Brownroach |
09-19-03 |
63 |
RE: HEY! |
ShowMeTheWinner |
09-20-03 |
67 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Acawap |
09-19-03 |
65 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
SnowBunny |
09-20-03 |
68 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Debster |
09-20-03 |
69 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
mavsfan |
09-20-03 |
70 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
SnowBunny |
09-21-03 |
74 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
aardvark_3 |
09-22-03 |
79 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Joyful |
09-20-03 |
72 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Jims02 |
09-21-03 |
75 |
Random thoughts... |
PhoenixMons |
09-21-03 |
77 |
Big Lie about Occupation? |
Krautboy |
09-21-03 |
78 |
RE: Big Lie about Occupation? |
VerucaSalt |
09-22-03 |
80 |
RE: Big Lie about Occupation? |
Loree |
09-22-03 |
82 |
RE: Big Lie about Occupation? |
VerucaSalt |
09-22-03 |
83 |
RE: Big Lie about Occupation? |
Loree |
09-22-03 |
86 |
RE: Big Lie about Occupation? |
reckhard |
09-22-03 |
89 |
RE: Big Lie about Occupation? |
DoodleBug |
09-22-03 |
92 |
Big Twist Possibility |
Chez |
09-22-03 |
81 |
JP's words.... |
smrtNsassybnkr |
09-22-03 |
84 |
RE: JP's words.... |
weltek |
09-22-03 |
85 |
Tiebreaker |
Jims02 |
09-22-03 |
87 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Oscirus |
09-22-03 |
90 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
Acawap |
09-22-03 |
91 |
RE: Big Lie, Big Twist Discussion |
VerucaSalt |
09-25-03 |
93 |
Reporter Confession or Coverup? |
mistofleas |
09-25-03 |
94 |
RE: Reporter Confession or Coverup? |
Krautboy |
09-25-03 |
95 |
RE: Reporter Confession or Coverup? |
VerucaSalt |
09-25-03 |
96 |
RE: Reporter Confession or Coverup? |
Brownroach |
09-25-03 |
97 |
RE: Reporter Confession or Coverup? |
tamarama |
09-25-03 |
108 |
RE: Reporter Confession or Coverup? |
VolcanicGlass |
09-25-03 |
98 |
RE: Reporter Confession or Coverup? |
tamarama |
09-25-03 |
106 |
RE: Reporter Confession or Coverup? |
TeamJoisey |
09-25-03 |
100 |
SF Radio station "big twist" |
citygirl |
09-25-03 |
99 |
RE: SF Radio station "big twist" |
TeamJoisey |
09-25-03 |
101 |
RE: SF Radio station "big twist" |
LeftPinky |
09-25-03 |
102 |
RE: SF Radio station "big twist" |
Brownroach |
09-25-03 |
103 |
RE: SF Radio station "big twist" |
mistofleas |
09-25-03 |
104 |
RE: SF Radio station "big twist" |
Brownroach |
09-25-03 |
105 |
Starting a new thread |
mistofleas |
09-25-03 |
107 |
|
|
p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e -
p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e -
p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e -
p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e -
|
|