The Amazing Race   American Idol   The Apprentice   The Bachelor   The Bachelorette   Big Brother   The Biggest Loser
Dancing with the Stars   So You Think You Can Dance   Survivor   Top Model   The Voice   The X Factor       Reality TV World
   
Reality TV World Message Board Forums
PLEASE NOTE: The Reality TV World Message Boards are filled with desperate attention-seekers pretending to be one big happy PG/PG13-rated family. Don't be fooled. Trying to get everyone to agree with you is like herding cats, but intolerance for other viewpoints is NOT welcome and respect for other posters IS required at all times. Jump in and play, and you'll soon find out how easy it is to fit in, but save your drama for your mama. All members are encouraged to read the complete guidelines. As entertainment critic Roger Ebert once said, "If you disagree with something I write, tell me so, argue with me, correct me--but don't tell me to shut up. That's not the American way."
"After the Dissolve, The Players, Th..."
Email this topic to a friend
Printer-friendly version of this topic
Bookmark this topic (Registered users only)
Previous Topic | Next Topic
Conferences Survivor Spoilers Forum (Protected)
Current Message

Risti 190 desperate attention whore postings
DAW Level: "Blistex Spokesperson"

03-05-04, 01:07 AM (EST)
Click to EMail Risti Click to send private message to Risti Click to view user profile Click to check IP address of the poster
28. "Narrators, Commentators, and Strate..."
Perhaps I've been a bit blind the last couple challenges, but a few things struck me on this episode. The narrators of the group have changed, some on an extreme level, some more subtly. Some of the changes could have been due to the nature of this episode, but I thought I'd post what I was thinking.

Mogo Mogo

With the King gone, the role of primary narrator for this tribe is up for grabs. We already saw many perspectives last week with the scheming going on, but this week they seemed to settle. Shi Ann is giving us alot of <b>commentary.</b> (To much for my tastes...and I liked her back in Thailand!) Lex seems to have settled in as the main <b>narrator,</b> something that was starting in previous episodes already. Jerry is still a voice being heard alot for commentary, but often in dissention with the rest of the tribe. Kathy told us her role at the very beginning, but then either I tuned out, or we didn't see much of her after that, beyond the 'don't talk about food'. Ethan was there, but <b>telling us his story, not the tribe's.</b> Colby didn't say much, but what he did say was signficant, and usually relating to strategy theory.

Chapera

Sue obviously had alot to say this episode. However, her storyline was focused on herself, not the tribe. I found it interesting that on this new tribe, Rupert's role as narrator seems to be closer to what it was in S7 then it was back in Saboga. Whereas Rob was often giving us the play by play in the tribe before, his role has shifted to something I'll discuss in a second. Rupert, on the other hand, let us know how Sue was dealing, brought us up to speed on the food/provider issue, and even gave the details of who was talking to him and Jenna about alliances. Rob seemed to move from narrator to strategist. He was the one who brought up how Sue's incident would affect the tribe. We see his thoughts on the Romber/Saboga alliance. His only comment about Rupert providing is that he will decide how long Rupert is around.

Alicia and Tom provided contrasting commentary. Alicia's was generally sympathetic - she seemed the most on Sue's side, while Tom's seemed to sum up the voice of 'let's move on with the game'. Both spoke alot more then Jenna, who seemed to almost disapear this episode. Amber had a few nice speeches at the end, much the way Kathy was portrayed when Jenna quit.

So...I'm a rookie at this, and I'm going off of a memory from 4 hours ago now, but these are my thoughts. The strategist roles(Colby/Kathy for MM, Rob for Chapera) are often used as set up for a fall. When people discuss their brilliant strategy, it very rarely comes true for much longer. We're at the point now where 'second stage' narrators are being developped, and Ethan and Rupert, both being providers, seem to be falling into those roles. This probably guarantees them a spot well into the merge, but beyond that is questionable. I should really watch the show again to look closer at the 'commentators'. Shi Ann, as much as she was grating on my nerves, didn't really have a negative commentary. She seemed quite deluded at times, but that 'I can see what you can't' attitude is sometimes a sign that the character will outlast their tribemates(Sometimes it's a sign that they're just crazy and will be going soon). Jerry's was more negative, and combined with the previews for next week I see her going into the 'hated-one' role.

Tom and Alicia confuse me. They're neither under the radar nor in the spotlight. All and all, that seems to suggest they'll be around for awhile. Jenna's sudden drop was probably one of the biggest surprises for me. I mean, I think we had more confessionals for Amber.

Speaking of Amber. Whatever can you say about Amber.

  Remove | Alert Edit | Reply | Reply With Quote | Top

Table of Contents
  Subject     Author     Message Date     ID  
 After the Dissolve, The Players, Th...   VerucaSalt     02-27-04       
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   VerucaSalt     02-27-04     1  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   raidersfantom     02-27-04     2  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   true     02-27-04     3  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   wendyp     02-27-04     4  
     RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   VerucaSalt     02-27-04     5  
         RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   Blow by Blow     02-27-04     6  
         RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   Flowerpower     02-27-04     7  
         RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   ADKer     02-27-04     11  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   managerr     02-27-04     8  
     RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   redbeard103152     02-27-04     17  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   Brownroach     02-27-04     9  
     RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   JohnMc     02-27-04     12  
     RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   VerucaSalt     02-27-04     13  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   memacmur     02-27-04     10  
   few quick thoughts   I_AM_HE     02-27-04     14  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   munson     02-27-04     15  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   bondt007     02-27-04     16  
     RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   VerucaSalt     02-28-04     18  
         RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   Chez     02-28-04     19  
             RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   VerucaSalt     02-28-04     20  
                 RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   pinchy     02-28-04     21  
                     RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   Cuauhtewatemoccajava     02-28-04     22  
                         RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   udg     02-29-04     23  
   Players Vs. Drama   Flowerpower     02-29-04     24  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   Rothschild     02-29-04     25  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   Flowerpower     03-04-04     26  
   Rupert   SnowBunny     03-04-04     27  
     RE: Rupert   okaloosajohn     03-05-04     35  
         RE: Rupert   Loree     03-05-04     36  
             RE: Rupert   I_AM_HE     03-05-04     37  
   Narrators, Commentators, and Strate...   Risti     03-05-04     28  
     RE: Narrators, Commentators, and St...   pinchy     03-05-04     29  
         RE: Narrators, Commentators, and St...   I_AM_HE     03-05-04     30  
   chapera and the reaction to sue   badger     03-05-04     31  
     RE: chapera and the reaction to sue   raidersfantom     03-05-04     32  
         RE: chapera and the reaction to sue   spastiman     03-05-04     33  
             RE: chapera and the reaction to sue   Loree     03-05-04     34  
   RE: After Sue; The Players, The Gam...   memacmur     03-05-04     38  
     RE: After Sue; The Players, The Gam...   I_AM_HE     03-05-04     39  
         RE: After Sue; The Players, The Gam...   memacmur     03-05-04     40  
             RE: After Sue; The Players, The Gam...   VerucaSalt     03-05-04     41  
                 RE: After Sue; The Players, The Gam...   Flowerpower     03-06-04     42  
                     RE: After Sue; The Players, The Gam...   Loree     03-06-04     43  
                         RE: After Sue; The Players, The Gam...   VerucaSalt     03-07-04     44  
                             RE: After Sue; The Players, The Gam...   VerucaSalt     03-09-04     45  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   Get Bent     03-10-04     46  
   The Robfadda Show   Flowerpower     03-10-04     47  
     RE: The Robfadda Show   Brownroach     03-10-04     48  
         RE: The Robfadda Show   VerucaSalt     03-10-04     49  
             RE: The Robfadda Show   Brownroach     03-10-04     50  
                 RE: The Robfadda Show   VerucaSalt     03-10-04     51  
                     RE: The Robfadda Show   redbeard103152     03-10-04     52  
                 RE: The Robfadda Show   Get Bent     03-11-04     54  
     RE: The Robfadda Show   Brat2u     03-23-04     100  
         RE: The Robfadda Show   emydi     03-23-04     101  
             RE: The Robfadda Show   Brownroach     03-23-04     102  
                 RE: The Robfadda Show   emydi     03-23-04     103  
                 RE: The Robfadda Show   Brat2u     03-24-04     105  
     RE: The Robfadda Show   ManateeBob     03-26-04     120  
   Sue's Web Chat   Get Bent     03-10-04     53  
   EP 7: Players, Game, Edit   EMT135     03-12-04     55  
     RE: EP 7: Players, Game, Edit   Flowerpower     03-12-04     56  
     RE: EP 7: Players, Game, Edit   SouperStar     03-12-04     57  
         RE: EP 7: Players, Game, Edit   VerucaSalt     03-12-04     58  
             Rupert...   udg     03-12-04     59  
             RE: EP 7: Players, Game, Edit   EMT135     03-12-04     60  
             RE: EP 7: Players, Game, Edit   raidersfantom     03-12-04     61  
                 RE: EP 7: Players, Game, Edit   ADKer     03-12-04     62  
     RE: EP 7: Players, Game, Edit   Brat2u     03-19-04     92  
         RE: EP 7: Players, Game, Edit   Brownroach     03-19-04     93  
   Tom   buckeyegirl     03-12-04     63  
     RE: Tom   VerucaSalt     03-12-04     64  
   RE: Episode 7 editting and characte...   memacmur     03-12-04     65  
     RE: Episode 7 editting and characte...   I_AM_HE     03-13-04     66  
         RE: Episode 7 editting and characte...   VerucaSalt     03-17-04     67  
   Episode 8 Updates   Get Bent     03-17-04     68  
     RE: Episode 8 Updates   VerucaSalt     03-18-04     69  
         RE: Episode 8 Updates   badger     03-18-04     70  
         RE: Episode 8 Updates   a98c4fun     03-18-04     72  
             RE: Episode 8 Updates   Loquatrix     03-18-04     77  
                 RE: Episode 8 Updates   Loree     03-18-04     79  
                     RE: Episode 8 Updates   Naked     03-19-04     82  
         RE: Episode 8 Updates   mtopaz     03-18-04     73  
         RE: Episode 8 Updates   Flowerpower     03-18-04     75  
             RE: Episode 8 Updates   Brownroach     03-18-04     76  
                 RE: Episode 8 Updates   Flowerpower     03-18-04     80  
     Rob & Rupert edit...   udg     03-19-04     88  
         RE: Rob & Rupert edit...   Loree     03-19-04     89  
         RE: Rob & Rupert edit...   Get Bent     03-19-04     90  
             RE: Rob & Rupert edit...   Loquatrix     03-19-04     94  
                 RE: Rob & Rupert edit...   I_AM_HE     03-19-04     95  
   The Amber edit   Loree     03-18-04     71  
     RE: The Amber edit   pinchy     03-18-04     74  
         RE: The Amber edit   VerucaSalt     03-18-04     78  
             RE: The Amber edit   Flowerpower     03-18-04     81  
                 RE: The Amber edit   VerucaSalt     03-19-04     83  
                     RE: The Amber edit   Flowerpower     03-19-04     84  
                     RE: The Amber edit   Loquatrix     03-19-04     85  
   Jerri   Oscirus     03-19-04     86  
     RE: Jerri   VerucaSalt     03-19-04     87  
     RE: Jerri   I_AM_HE     03-19-04     91  
         RE: Kathy   ADKer     03-19-04     97  
     RE: Jerri   Oscirus     03-22-04     98  
         RE: Jerri   VerucaSalt     03-23-04     99  
             RE: Jerri   DRONES     03-24-04     104  
   Episode 8   memacmur     03-19-04     96  
     Jerri stands a chance   RyrieRae     03-24-04     106  
         RE: Jerri stands a chance   VerucaSalt     03-24-04     107  
         RE: Jerri stands a chance   memacmur     03-24-04     109  
             Jerri=Neleh?   I_AM_HE     03-24-04     110  
                 RE: Jerri=Neleh?   Brownroach     03-24-04     111  
                     RE: Jerri=Neleh?   memacmur     03-24-04     112  
     RE: Episode 8   popsicle     03-24-04     108  
   RE: After the recrap   Flowerpower     03-24-04     113  
     RE: After the recrap   I_AM_HE     03-25-04     114  
     RE: After the recrap   DRONES     03-25-04     115  
         RE: After the recrap   VerucaSalt     03-25-04     116  
             RE: After the recrap   Brownroach     03-25-04     117  
                 RE: After the recrap   Cuauhtewatemoccajava     03-25-04     118  
                     RE: After the recrap   VerucaSalt     03-26-04     119  
             RE: After the recrap   DRONES     03-29-04     121  
             RE: After the recrap   geg6     03-29-04     122  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   Flowerpower     03-29-04     123  
     RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   VerucaSalt     03-30-04     124  
         RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   geg6     03-30-04     125  
   After the tribal swap: The Players,...   Flowerpower     04-02-04     126  
     RE: After the tribal swap: The Play...   cdlafl     04-02-04     128  
   Jenna L. vote   Simom72     04-02-04     127  
     RE: Jenna L. vote   bdemoney     04-02-04     129  
   RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   CRyanShort     04-02-04     130  
     RE: After the Dissolve, The Players...   fredscott     04-02-04     132  
   Amber's reaction   buckeyegirl     04-02-04     131  
     RE: Amber's reaction   yensid     04-02-04     133  

Lobby | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic

p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e - p l a c e h o l d e r t e x t g o e s h e r e -
about this site   •   advertise on this site  •   contact us  •   privacy policy   •