It has been rumored that the cruise ship spoiler is off a few days and John and Tammy are really the 8th and 9 off, both on jury. If this is the case, it comports with Kathy 4/11, then John and Tammy, then perhaps Rob.

I think the Gina comment on Rob "playing stupid" has more to do with early Mara. votes and conduct than later in the game. He is at a total disadvantage now and we know he is playing the game, so getting booted anytime from here on out is expected. How much "stupid" is required now? It really comes down to what N/P/K are going to do, because he knows he needs them. Bringing up Zoe's lie and the Rotu 4 alliance is smart - it is his only option, and we know from the previews that he does that in some fashion.

Gina could easily have gotten a better impression of Rob after the show wrapped. IMHO, finding him to be a great person outside the game does not in any way prove Rob goes to Loser Lodge. Remember T-Bird on Diane's friends list and the Carl reference to her? That really threw us. This is even less concrete. I also think that had Rob gone to Loser Lodge, we'd have more info. on a Rob/Sara liason, which seems to have died at the switch. If they were attracted to each other sweaty and stinky on the island, can you imagine a nice big hotel room, hot showers and toothpaste?

It could logically go this way K, J, T, R. John, trying to stay true to his word, votes off Kathy (she annoys everyone anyway) and Rob joins in to prove he's keeping his word. After Kathy goes, N/P are scared and join R/S/V to save their skins and vote off J & T.

With Rob no longer needed for a majority, his alliance turns on him at their first opp.

This is not to say that any/all of the spoilers are credible, just that it could all work out this way and stay true to the spoilers, if we don't read too much into Gina's Rob comment.

Does anyone have any more solid evidence on the cruise ship or Kathy items?