One of the best and most successful front men who never got along with his band was Jim Morrison. Axl Rose was also a tempermental hard to get along with type. Point is, sometimes talent and creativity overcomes all the personality defects. If INXS wants a yes man with no creativity for front man, they can play it safe with Ty or Deanna or Jessica (she's only ever written about 6 songs). MiG, Jordis and Suzie show some spark of creativity and quite a bit of singing ability. The only ones who can both sing and are creative seem to be Marty (unless one considers that absolute travesty during the teamwork competition) and JD.

Add in the fact that controversy causes the media to take notice and splash one's pictures everywhere, which increases album sales. Madonna is a prime example of this, her career has been very carefully orchestrated to create controversy in the beginning to get herself noticed, then allow her talent to show in the middle phase, and now she's considered a mega star. Anyway, it is indeed possible that INXS will choose JD. My husband, on the other hand, thinks that they've already made up their minds, and that MiG will be the winner.