I couldn't agree more with what you have said about the show going down hill. The judges spend more time making fun of each other than they do being serious about their role as judges. After all, these people have pretty impressive credentials, for celebrity judges, so why don't they act a bit more like professionals?

The voting system on American Idol isn't working. And despite what some people who have responded here have said, there has NEVER been more shock and controversy expressed over someone leaving the show early as there has been over Chris. He came out every week and performed well. He has a great singing voice. Yes, he is rock oriented. Big deal. Last year's Idol winner was a country western singer, and that didn't stop her from being successful. And Chris will, likewise, be a success.

I completely disagree with those who say Chris is not versatile. He can sing powerful rock songs and tender ballads with equal effectiveness. He is a great singer. The judges, the other contestants, and millions of viewers (read all the reviews of last night's show if you don't believe me) were stunned last night when Ryan Seacrest announced Chris would be leaving the show. Something isn't right here.