we don't need judges,the america people vote not the judges,why do you need a save if the people voted them off they should stay off,
why do the american people vote if your just going to put the idol
back in the ranks,and about siobham magnus i think she is great ,i am sure with practice she could sing the same octave as mariah carey "why should we waste our time to vote if you put them back in" also i wish you would have never stopped recording the top 12 singers of each season like you have in the pasted --you should not have a save it is not fare, and why 4 judges? you should have 2 or 3 then each week a guest judge --being simon is leaving for his own show x factor i bet he will take some of your watchers-when paula was gone you didn't need to replace her,my god what is the american idol coming to ---judges--saves-whats next
and i heard they want idol mom lets get realllll
i don't know if your going like what i said , but i will write what i feel free speech well that is enough for now
sweet dreams