LAST EDITED ON 12-22-14 AT 07:06 PM (EST)You'd be surprised to learn there's only been seven Kellys/Kelley in the game (eight if you count Reed Kelly):
Kelly Wiglesworth
Kelly Goldsmith
Kelly Czarnecki
Kelly Sharbaugh
Kelly Bruno
Purple Kelly Shinn
Kelley Wentworth
Would Kel Gleason count on this list? If so, make it eight.
There's been 12 Johns, including variations such as Jon and Jonathan (John Carroll, John Cochran, John Cody, Jon 'Jonny Fairplay' Dalton, John Fincher, John Kenney, Jonathan Libby, Jon Misch, John Palyok, Jonathan Penner, John Raymond, John Rocker, and technically you could add one more for Bobby Jon Drinkard)
ETA: Other common names...
11 - James/variations (James 'Chad' Crittenden, James 'J.T.' Thomas, James Clement, James 'Rocky' Reid, Jimmy Tarantino, Jimmy Johnson, James Miller, Jamie Newton, Jim Rice, Jim Lynch, Jaime Dugan)
8 - Robert/variations (Robert DeCanio, Rob Mariano, Rob Cesternino, Bobby Mason, Bob Crowley, Robb Zbacnik, Bobby Jon Drinkard, Roberta 'RC' Saint-Amour)
7 - Michael (Michael Skupin, Michael 'Frosti' Zernow, Michael Jefferson, Michael Snow, Mike Borassi, Mike Chiesl, Mikey Bortone)
7 - Chris/variations (Chris Daugherty, Christy Smith, Christa Hastie, Christina Cha, Christine Shields Markoski, Krista Klumpp, Kristina Kell)
6 - Matthew (Matthew von Ertfelda, Matt Bischoff, Matt Elrod, Matt Quinlan, Matthew 'Sash' Lenahan, Matty Whitmore)
6 - Katherine/variations (Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien, Kathleen Sleckman, Kat Edorsson, Katie Gallagher, Katie Hanson, Katie Collins)
5 - Kim (Kim Johnson, Kim Powers, Kimmi Kappenberg, Kim Mullen, Kim Spradlin)
5 - David (Dave Cruser, David Ball, Dave Johnson, David Murphy, David Samson)
5 - Daniel (Dan Barry, Dan Kay, Danny G.C. Brown, Dan Lembo, Daniel Lue) I put Danni/Danielle in a separate category.
The name with the highest rate of success in the game is Natalie - there's been 4 of them, with their finishes being 1st (Anderson), 1st (White), 3rd (Tenerelli) and 4th (Bolton).