LAST EDITED ON 05-17-07 AT 07:54 AM (EST)

First of all I have never been a Charlie fan so it was with some glee I saw the name of the episode and the possiblility he is gone(I am completely spoiler free).

Having said that...that was a tense episode! He did a great job. I actually felt sad and was hoping he would not die! Him swimming under the hatch was agonizing. I was so scared they actually might show him gasping for breath and drowning. I was relieved when he came up! Then I expected that something might fall down on him or those women would shoot him right there. They totally got me buying that he was going to buy it!(Although as someone alludes to up there it could be setting him up to die in the finale-I hope that is just speculation and not a spoiler here)

Couple of things.

1. Flashbacks. Not entirely enlightning. When he was singing in the rain was that where Desmond saw him? Have we seen the woman that he saved yet?(EDITED-I have since perused the internet and see that it was Nadia, funny I thought her accent sounded Scandanavian last night not Iraqi) What about the mugger? Was he anyone?

2. Does Charlie have any Daddy issues? Somehow I don't recall any?

3. Interesting the ring was left behind. Does that mean anything?

4. Does Ben know about the women in the hatch or are they still remnants of Dharma? Did Ben know about Desmond in the other hatch?

Decent episode. I hope Charlie makes it. Oh and the chick who plays Alex is really pretty.

A PhoenixMons Creation