I thought you'd know I always appreciated you so I don't understand your last sentence. The list that Dabo posted wasn't his. He imported one from a blogger and I'm telling him that there are thousands of lists that could be imported also.
I don't belittle opinions unless they are laughable. When someone writes that Amazon is bad because, take away Rob, Jenna and Heidi, you have nothing left, then that deserves a laugh.
I would say that the objective of this kind of list is to share your preferences, encouraging others to appreciate the seasons you liked. That means having a discussion and I can't have a discussion with a blogger that never posted on this board.
So, I'm curious why you liked Philippines so much and didn't like Amazon. I'm guessing that it's because you liked one winner a lot and not the other but you didn't explain. If that is your main reason then I will simply say that we don't use the same criteria to determine the value of a season. It wouldn't be you that I wouldn't take seriously, it would be your list. I couldn't use it to help me see the value of a particular season because the winner's identity is low on my checklist.
A good season is an entertaining one. The best seasons have 14 entertaining episodes. Philippines had the worse pre-merge until it was "topped" by Caramoan's bad joke. At most, it had maybe 3 or 4 good episodes which isn't enough for me.
Amazon was hilarious and, even if you didn't like seeing Jenna win, that final episode was still thrilling until Rob lost the Final IC.