But you are missing my point: If Bill was ready to go with the majority in deciding to give up immunity then it follows that he would have gone with the majority if the men had been up 7-5 at the merge. To say he'd flip is preposterous from what we knew of him.
If the men had gone up 8-6, like they were supposed to, the tribal switch may have given them a majority on both tribes.

As for your new "arguments"
1) The one time Colton had a choice, he booted a woman. To say he was one of them is refusing to face the facts.

2) Your strong guys fragmented Manono before Colton had the HII. AND Troyzan was the one on the divinding line that ultimately chose to vote against Michael and Jay so at least he doesn't deserve to say his elimination would be anti-Darwinism.

3) That happened much later. Jonas told us in interviews that, as soon as they merged, he knew Troyzan and Jay were with the women. He knew he wasn't in an alliance with them anymore. So Troyzan and Jay have only themselves to blame if the women stay together.

Anyway, when you talk of Anti-Darwinism you are acting as if the guys with the most muscles should be given a free pass to the F4 because no one should be allowed to vote them out. Survivor does't work that way and neither does survival. Brains matter more.