LAST EDITED ON 04-05-08 AT 11:30 PM (EST)

I don't agree. Of course, the Steph- BJ tie-breaker was a different scenario; I don't think anyone needed to be reminded of that, but the fact still stands that EVERY tie-breaker since Marquesas has been a fire challenge. Every one. We have not seen the purple rock again. In Marquesas it was the F4 when the purple rock happened. We have had two F4 ties since then, and no purple rock. So, if the purple rock was removed for the F4, why would it still be the tie-breaker at F6 or beyond? Show me where the rule is written that it would be the purple rock. Or have someone involved with the show say that is the case. Then I would accept that as fact. Otherwise, I don't see the logic in removing it from the F4, but then keeping it for other times in the game.
And as it turns out, Ami was gone the following week anyway. So, obviously, even if it was the purple rock, Ami would have been better off to take a 50-50 shot versus playing it safe and being booted the following week.
Lisa wasn't in the alliance? Is Lisa a woman? Then, according to Ami, she was in the alliance. Even if she were not, she still was booted at that particular time for one reason only, because she got on Ami's bad side. So, yeah, Ami did have a bad side. No editing needed to show that.

>