LAST EDITED ON 04-12-06 AT 01:27 PM (EST)

LAST EDITED ON 04-10-06 AT 12:37 PM (EST)

PASSENGER STATUS
1) She was never on the plane...she is an "other" that planted herself in the group.
Q: How did she and Goodwin act around eachother? I know she played a careful balance between "let him go/Ana, you know best."

2) She was coincidentally on the same plane as Hurley
Q: Why doesn't she recognize him...big shaggy hair guy she stared at would be memorable.

3) She was purposely on the same plane as Hurley
Q: Why?

MENTAL PATIENT STATUS
1) She was a patient for unknown reason, completely coincidence Hurley was also there & they showed up on the same plane later
Q. No question here..it's not really an option for this show.

2) She was once a psychologist, but someone or something made her turn crazy & was admited to the psych hospital
Q. Was she recruited by Dharma to work for them...but then flipped out? Was she under stress, went to see a colleague for counseling that was part of Dharma & thought she'd be a good subject for their "experiments"? Did she accidentally witness some Dharma activity & they punished her by making her think she's crazy & medicating her?

3) She was never a psychologist, but only a patient, yet pretends she's a psychologist.
Q. What's her motive for manipulating Hurley? Did she really forget about "knowing" him from the hospital? Is she just so crazy that she likes to act like a psychologist?

4) She was a patient turned psychologist
Q. I don't think there was enough physical time lapse between Hurley's hospitalization & the crash to give her enough time to get out & get her education & practice.

5) Dharma recruited her while in the hospital. She is being used as a tool in their experiments.
Q. To what end? Were they simultaneously using Hurley and Libby in the hospital...maybe for different means? Did they give her enough training/info to make her an imposter psychologist?

6) Stalker Libby: As mentioned by a poster above, maybe she's just obsessed with Hurley after seeing him in the institution.
Q. What does this really add to the storyline? Is she stalking him because her loved one was killed in the accident Hurley caused? Is she after his money?

Thoughts & additions welcome & appreciated!