LAST EDITED ON 11-07-12 AT 01:06 AM (EST)My other thought is that there must be a huge amount of demand for furniture in the NYC area after last week's storm.
Yes, it's been all over the news that in the aftermath of Hurricane Sandy there's been a critical shortage of pianos in the NYC area. Some people have been lined up at the Steinway showroom for days.
CT, is it a good piano? You might want to get it looked at by a local tuner or restorer before offering it for sale. Otherwise I've not used Craig's list, so, no advice.
ETA: Oops I didn't see your post about it being a player piano. Still, a local dealer or restorer might be interested in it.