Wild guess on the next elimination -

My twisted little brain has come up with the following, which would be terrible.

Amy gets to choose first because she is odd woman out. She can choose whomever she wants and that person can't be chosen by anyone else. An almost visible lightbulb goes off above Amy's head ("by Jove I think she's got it!") and she FINALLY realizes it is a GAME and chooses Kieth to get rid of Tara. (Kieth then says "you have to be f'in kiddin' me" and starts to cry. Ummm, wait, no, that's been done.)

Then Holly chooses Scott. Then, very predictably, both Tara and Charla choose Dave, and then Amanda says:

Well Dave, who do you choose? Tara or Charla? Dave does his best to soften the blow to Tara.

Then Amanda says (in a slightly patronizing tone):

Well, Dave, I asked you who you chose, but I didn't say it would matter, because none of you are in one of the final two set couples, all three of you are eliminated.

Yikes.