A surprising week, in more ways than one...1 - Lee Dewyze - Treat Her Like A Lady - Why they didn't get Lee the pimp spot is a shock. Best performance of the night, and Lee has finally found his comfort zone on Idol. Watch out. He could surprise us all.
2 - Crystal - Midnight Train - For a song that has been overdone, she brought new life to it and switched it up. Love this girl.
3 - Casey - Hold On - Like Crystal, he knows who he is and he's finally getting the respect he deserves from the judges
4 - Andrew - Forever - FINALLY the Andrew we loved from Hollywood finds his way back. Excellent performance and he too has gained confidence.
--- GAP ---
5 - Michael - Ready For Love - I didn't know the song, but he did it well. Excellent pitch on that song.
6 - Aaron - Aint No Sunshine - Pretty good, he's been better.
7 - Katie - Like Aaron, pretty good. I agree, i cna't see a 17 year old singing that song...but...
--- GAP ---
8 - Siobhan - Through The Fire - Wow, what happened to Siobhan. Not good, pitch was all off, out of tune, shocking.
9 - Didi - What Becomes... - Agree with the judges 100%, flat, boring.
10 - Tim - Sweet Love - Wow, most obscure song choice ever on Idol?? Bizarre. I love the song but can anyone other than Anita Baker sing that one? I don't think so, and especially not Tim Urban. High School Talent Night.
geekboy
"I think what Randy Travis was trying to say was 'What the hell was that?!'" - S. Cowell
Email this topic to a friend
Printer-friendly version of this topic
Bookmark this topic (Registered users only)
Rankings - Top 10 - R&B Week
