Again I kept saying as I was going thru the show via DVR "When is this gonna be over?" (Hint: watch another show for a nice diversion Last nite I watched Modern Family in between to lighten my mood What a great show. Mommy!)

But not quite as bad as last nite or last week (both)

1. Crystal-again the best for me went first. Idol wants a big start and puts someone there that is in no way in trouble...I loved this song, it was the best of year so far for me

2. Paige-I liked that I think she does have a very good voice. And shut up Kara about writing it and telling her she should know exactly what you were thinking...again it's all about her for Kara

3. Katelyn-I like this, her voice Plus bonus-- she makes faces! and she IS a pretty thing isn't she Glowie?

4. Katie-I liked this more than the judges and more than last week. I like the tone of her voice

5. Sibhon-I thought the song choice was bad and the glory note was screaching but I really like Sibhon she is the real quirk
this year

6. Lilly-meh she destroyed the song and while Crystal is authentic and Sibhon is quirky imho, Lilly is forcing it, whatever IT is. I want her to play that toy flute thing on stage though!

7. Haeley-omh Miley Cyrus...well at least she actually sang the song...Kara says she needs another year...so why not give it to her and not put her in top 24? She's so VFTW-worthy though and she'll be safe

8. Lacey-I want to like her more but she just isn't bringing it...this was bad

9. Michelle-Creed, really, Creed? Why not Nickelback? Ugh this was horrible song choice and she made this ##### poor song even worse, if that's even possible?

10. Didi-omh she is awful..what an awful song choice and I really do not like the tone of her voice. I'm surprised she didn't pull a Gokey and say she picked it bc it reminds her of her bff