I would not chose Avocado, although I like him on the show, because I think he tends to be preachy--something I really detest.
Fiona seems laking in depth. I think for her Wicca is just another cool costume.
I would chose Don to walk around my neighborhood with, just for the shock & awe effect. After, we'd go to my health food store, Valley Co-op, then bar hop for Bloody Marys. I think he would be fun to hang with, but nobody I want to emulate.
I would chose either Art or Iya ta'Shia (my first choice) to actually talk to. And I don't mind having my fortune told--I see that as just one path my life may follow. The choice of how I walk my path remains mine.
Interesting, because ta'Shia was the Alt I liked least in the beginning.