LAST EDITED ON 09-18-05 AT 08:20 PM (EST)

Could've written what happened before the show - they were all just so "them."

Marty - Very prepared, came in with strong ideas of what he thought the songs should be. Lots of talent. Andrew praised working with him.

MiG - Also prepared. On the light side, Andrew had some "let's make it darker" suggestions. Andrew also praised working with him (but I got between the lines that he thought Marty was more talented.)

JD - Had ideas, but not fleshed out. Andrew had expected more, but JD works/thinks very quickly and they produced. Andrew thinks JD has the passion and the talents but could use some of Marty's discipline.

During the song selection - they got to choose their own song out of any that have been performed the whole time. Was Marty being a little evil, encouraging MiG to sing BoRhap when he thought it was a bad idea for MiG? At first, he was neutral ("it's your choice" but then he was encouraging him "I'd love to hear you do it." I'm sure he would!

I only hope JD's performance of "You Can't Always Get What you Want" Tuesday is as good as it was as the show was closing. The most feeling/passion I've heard from him.