Just because he does not and never has wanted to play kumbaya with them does not make him a bad person. Oh, but he has....until he could really no longer get away with it. That little tatoo parade with MIG....Human Being.....Being Human...no you Pahleeze missy. There are other examples. The people in the house see him for who he really is, whether they are passive aggressive or not.
And I've said in the past that JD has talent as a singer, arranger, and writer. I've never questioned that. But this also has to be a personality contest. INXS also has to live with him, and for that reason, if they chose him, they will regret it. He will eventually posture himself as bigger and better than the band itself, just like he already thinks he's bigger and better than everyone in the house.
Moves courtesy of Syren