You bring up a good point...who was encore worthy this week? I think JD, Suzie & Deanna are the only contenders. They might give it to Deanna because it may be her only chance to do an original...given they'll probably boot her.
JD had a really solid performance & was hoping to grab the band & remind them he's good. They might give it to him to say "we noticed."
Suzie is an INXS favorite & she was good last night. It's a fun song. they know she needs an ego boost.
After deliberation with myself, I agree that Suzie will get the encore.