Glass Eye was redundant. We already knew that Will could do cute, silent films.
Jason's movie was incomprehensible. For that alone, he deserves to lose.
Zach's was the best of the rest. It was cute and well-produced. Not really a drama without special effects like he promised, but was decent for what it was.
I actually think I would have loved Mateen's film if he'd had a different male lead actor. The female lead was excellent. . . that's probably why he spent all his time focusing in on her. But overall, Mateen's film was weak because of the male lead.
Jessica, jessica, jessica. I wish you'd gone the first week and we could have seen the work of either of the two chicks who went before you, rather THAN you. You are too sophomoric. Experimental has its place. Just not in a competition for "America's Favorite Filmmaker!"