"She is here because she won the comps, not because she is smart."What on earth are you talking about? The majority of the comps that she's won have been competitions involving memory and observation, not brawn. She's won almost ALL of her comps because she is a smart, keen and observative player. You can say what you will about her nominations but she's outsmarted EVERYONE in almost all of the competitions that she's won. Will hasn't won a competition. And yes, that seems to be a large part of his plan. Still, he HASN'T won a comp and we don't really know if he would have if he tried. His scheming is smart. Her competition skills are smart. Neither are stupid.
"She is dumb because she could have cut loose Boogie but she cut loose CG."
Yeah, I forgot. She voted CG out, didn't she? What show are you watching? Erika had the power to vote against Boogie and she didn't. Five or six others had the chance to put up Chilltown, but didn't. Yet Janie is the "dumb" one. I just love that logic. Chicken George had to go. he was useless in competitions and EVERYONE could have benefited from keeping him around. Getting rid of Chicken George means that everyone has to play the game, including the competitions. Janie has proved better than all of them at that. Yeah, so she's the dumb one, isn't she?
She is dumb because she let her crush on Will cloud any judgements on the game. I can go on and on, but need I?
Really? I guess all those competition wins were the result of clouded judgment? I guess that fact that she's still in the game is the result of clouded judgment. I guess that a final HOH win and a spot in the final two will all be the result of Will's hold over her. Geez, he can take hold of me any time.
"If she loses a competition than we can really see how smart it was to trust him because at that time we will see if he does something which helps her."
See, here's the kink in your logic. She hasn't lost a competition, so whether or not Will is playing her or if she was smart to trust him is a moot point. We don't know and may never know if she wins HOH. You're whole theory is shot for the simple reason that it can't be proven. Will has never been in the position to hurt or help her so...what exactly is your point?
"That is SO WRONG. She is in the final 3 because of how she played the competitions, not who she alligned herself with. Your statement directly infers that she is in the final 3 because in part of alligning herself with CT. Please explain how aligning herself with CT as opposed to others helped her."
Again, what's with the hedging of the issue? You've done nothing to disprove the other poster's suggestions. Since Janie was never on the block at the end of the week(because of winning the vetoes), we'll never know if the alliance would have hurt or helped her. CT could have done nothing to sway her nominations(because she was such a target) but they may very well have helped her stay. we don't know...EITHER WAY. We may not have seen any direct benefits from the alliance but that doesn't mean we wouldn't have. You have no proof that the alliance was, as you put it so eloquently, "dumb".
"Since Jani pretty much won everything, her dominance in competions put her in a postion where if she worked it right she chould could have had anyone she wanted to in the final 4 with her."
Again, are we watching the same show? Janelle would have lost to Danielle. If she kept James, she probably would have been ousted due to his backstabbing. She may have won against Chicken George, but with him in the house she'd be a bigger target. WIth Erika in the house(for the final 3), she'd be playing both competitions against Boogie and Erika(who both can play). Unless Will is in danger, Janelle will only have to worry about Boogie in both comps. Hmmm, I think I'll take the odds she's given herself rather than yours.
"Will beats her hands down if they both get to the finals - if you consider keeping a guy like that around as being anything but dumb than that is your opinion"
Really? I guess I've over-looked your keen powers of observation. How every did I miss them in your posts so far?
Howie will vote for Janie. Before she left the house, Danielle indicated an affinity for Janie. Chicken George will vote for Janie. And James, after he was booted, indicated that she's an amazing player and will probably win. Hmmm, wonder who he might vote for?
Will only has Boogie's vote for sure. Erika, the dumb tramp that she is, will probably vote for him as well.
Then there's Marcellas who knows that CT is the reason he was VOTED out. He blames Janelle for the nominations. That vote could go either way.
Work on those numbers and logic and get back to me. I wasn't going to respond but Janie is not "dumb" or "stupid". You can critique her nominations and play as much as you want, but she's made it much farther than the so called smart gamers.