Let's figure this out! Someone goes to exile island and is payed a visit by a former Survivor.....who could it be?

1. First of all, I think only a winner would be impactful or in a position to offer any kind of advice.

2. If it's a winner, who are the candidates? (Won't be Tony/JT/Sandra)
Seriously doubt it would be Heidek, doubtful that it's Tina, Vecepia: no. Amber: doubtful, Danni Boatwright?, Todd, Bob Crowley, Natalie White, Fabio, Sophie, Denise, Natalie

Possible Candidates: Hatch, Jenna?, Boston Rob, Tom, Aras, Yul, Earl, Parvati, Kim, Cochran, Tyson, Jeremy, Mike Holloway.

3. If it's not a winner, who? Terry Dietz, RussHell?

Frankly, I think it could be Hatch? Boston Rob? Yup? Tyson? Terry?

• RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,Corvis7, 09:12 AM, 03-31-17
  • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,michel2, 01:45 PM, 03-31-17
    • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,Flowerpower1, 05:36 PM, 03-31-17
  • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,Sheldor, 05:47 PM, 03-31-17
    • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,Outsider32, 01:57 PM, 04-01-17
      • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,Outsider32, 01:58 PM, 04-01-17
      • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,CTgirl, 10:14 AM, 04-02-17
• RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,CTgirl, 12:47 PM, 04-01-17
  • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,PepeLePew13, 07:28 AM, 04-03-17
  • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,Sheldor, 03:39 PM, 04-03-17
    • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,Brownroach, 06:49 PM, 04-03-17
      • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,Flowerpower1, 07:33 AM, 04-05-17
        • RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,Sheldor, 11:40 AM, 04-05-17
• RE: Who is the mystery Visitor,RachelOH1, 11:18 PM, 04-07-17

The producers love Boston Rob...

and since we all know that there are the Boston Rob rules I guess they'll want him as coach.

"coach"....yup, I thought about him too since he was so good at exile island. Well, perhaps exile island yoga.

Corvis7 wrote: "The producers love Boston Rob..."

Especially EXECUTIVE Producer Jeff Probst!

And isn't Tribephyl's post of Boston Rob's daughters wearing all 4 colored buffs from this season pretty compelling evidence that the Visitor is in fact Boston Rob?

Caleb had made a tweet that he would be back after he was voted out on screen(according to a Sucks post). I'll get the link to the post soon as I don't read his social media. It was implied maybe he was talking about coming back for a third season or Big Brother All-Stars. He said he's not going to name spoilers, just that he will be back.

So it could be him and Tai is exiled?

My other theory is Andrea is exiled and Phillip shows up.

I don't consider these spoilers btw as there is nothing conclusive it is him coming back.

Well nvm now, just saw the post below.

There is some game show called Candy Crush Saga (I think) that is premiering with Survivor and Big Brother contestants. Caleb will be on that.

Boston Rob tweeted out this morning to confirm that he is the one returning to Survivor this week!

"Officially got the okay to let you all know that Yes I will be returning to @survivorcbs this week Be sure to tune in to @CBS this Wednesday"

Yeah I figured out that it was BRob last week when I checked his twitter feed and saw he had a three-week gap in June, which just so happened to be during the filming period for this season. He was quite active before and after that three-week gap.

Most likely true but that Tweet by Boston Rob was made on April 1, 2017 (April Fool's Day in the U.S.)

LAST EDITED ON 04-04-17 AT 00:49 AM (EST)

Nice catch, Sheldor. And since when does anyone "get the okay" from producers to reveal anything about the show, never mind a surprise appearance? Though I suppose they really don't care anymore...

Boston Rob.....YAY!

LAST EDITED ON 04-05-17 AT 12:05 PM (EST)

Not that Survivor is fair...

It would seem most fair for the Former Player/Winner to have never played with any player this season.

Winners that have not played with any players this season:

Richard Hatch
Ethan Zohn
Vecepia Towery
Brian Heidik
Jenna Morasca
Amber Brkich
Chris Daugherty
Tom Westman
Danni Boatwright
Earl Cole
Todd Herzog
Bob Crowley
Natalie White
Jud "Fabio" Birza
Natalie Anderson

Also...

Jud "Fabio" Birza was a guest on People PEN Fan Forum Survivor

Mike Holloway was a guest on YouTube SurvivorOnCBS: Beyond The Buff (but of course Mike played with Sierra and Hali)

Natalie Anderson was a last minute cut from Game Changers

I would love it if they keep bringing a different "mystery visitor" every week to Exile! That would explain Boston Rob's buffs on his daughters! ;) I suppose that will take too much time out of the episode... but I like that idea!