URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID69
Thread Number: 714
[ Go back to previous page ]

Original Message
"Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by mrc on 02-23-07 at 10:14 AM

Okay, so she's not as talented as Kat. She has more of a Broadway voice, which I find marginally interesting. But the girl is HOT!!! I think she is my swoony pick of this year's gaggle.
What is Phil's golf equipment?

Table of contents

RE: Haley is my new Kat,Glow, 12:48 PM, 02-23-07
- RE: Haley is my new Kat,mrc, 02:13 PM, 02-23-07
  - RE: Haley is my new Kat,Glow, 03:29 PM, 02-23-07
    - RE: Haley is my new Kat,mrc, 03:36 PM, 02-23-07
    - RE: Haley is my new Kat,Angelflutter, 07:09 PM, 04-02-07
      - RE: Haley is my new Kat,agman, 07:21 PM, 04-02-07
    - RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 11:04 AM, 04-04-07
      - RE: Haley is my new Kat,nailbone, 02:14 PM, 04-04-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 02:34 PM, 04-04-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,agman, 02:50 PM, 04-04-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 03:36 PM, 04-04-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,agman, 02:52 PM, 04-04-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 03:37 PM, 04-04-07
RE: Haley is my new Kat,nailbone, 04:20 PM, 02-23-07
RE: Haley is my new Kat,brvnkrz, 12:13 PM, 02-24-07
- RE: Haley is my new Kat,mrc, 03:51 PM, 02-24-07
  - RE: Haley is my new Kat,motormouth, 03:48 AM, 02-25-07
RE: Haley is my new Kat,SilverStar, 03:42 PM, 02-26-07
- Ahem.,mrc, 10:41 AM, 03-01-07
RE: Haley is my new Kat,mrc, 10:38 AM, 03-01-07
RE: Haley is my new Kat,mrc, 03:57 PM, 03-08-07
- RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 04:04 PM, 03-08-07
- RE: Haley is my new Kat,YankeeDixieDoodle, 04:20 PM, 03-09-07
RE: Haley is my new Kat,bullzeye, 06:36 PM, 03-08-07
- RE: Haley is my new Kat,nailbone, 10:27 AM, 03-09-07
  - RE: Haley is my new Kat,bullzeye, 10:54 AM, 03-09-07
RE: Haley is my new Kat,SherpaDave, 05:26 PM, 03-09-07
Ok, last night?,nailbone, 09:00 AM, 03-21-07
- RE: Just OK Last Night,LisaPles, 09:58 AM, 03-21-07
- RE: Ok, last night?,priestdi, 10:02 AM, 03-21-07
  - RE: Ok, last night?,nailbone, 11:22 AM, 03-21-07
RE: Haley is my new Kat,joannie, 03:14 PM, 03-22-07
RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 04:47 PM, 03-27-07
- RE: Haley is my new Kat,Magnolia_Rocker, 08:04 AM, 03-28-07
  - RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 10:39 AM, 03-28-07
    - RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 10:42 AM, 03-28-07
      - RE: Haley is my new Kat,nailbone, 02:19 PM, 03-28-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,Magnolia_Rocker, 02:26 PM, 03-28-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 02:57 PM, 03-28-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,nailbone, 03:31 PM, 03-28-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 04:02 PM, 03-28-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 12:45 PM, 03-29-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 02:15 PM, 04-01-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,LisaPles, 03:57 PM, 04-04-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,bob_chester, 04:47 PM, 04-04-07
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,YankeeDixieDoodle, 06:50 PM, 04-05-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,habman, 09:23 AM, 04-06-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,bullzeye, 11:06 AM, 04-06-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,Snidget, 08:29 PM, 04-07-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,prosecutor, 08:21 PM, 04-07-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,joannie, 09:08 PM, 04-07-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,agman, 10:14 PM, 04-07-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,Fishercat, 00:11 AM, 04-08-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,YankeeDixieDoodle, 03:11 PM, 04-09-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,agman, 03:21 PM, 04-09-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,YankeeDixieDoodle, 03:40 PM, 04-09-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,YankeeDixieDoodle, 03:32 PM, 04-09-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,agman, 03:35 PM, 04-09-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,YankeeDixieDoodle, 01:57 PM, 04-11-07
        
        RE: Haley is my new Kat,agman, 11:25 AM, 04-12-07
Okay, I'll do it if no one else will,mrc, 03:30 PM, 04-12-07
- RE: Okay, I'll do it if no one else will,nailbone, 03:53 PM, 04-12-07
  - RE: Okay, I'll do it if no one else will,YankeeDixieDoodle, 04:23 PM, 04-12-07
  - RE: Okay, I'll do it if no one else will,agman, 04:37 PM, 04-12-07
- waiting for the spread...photo spread that is...,curveball, 04:06 PM, 04-12-07
  - RE: waiting for the spread...photo spread that is...,YankeeDixieDoodle, 04:18 PM, 04-12-07
    - RE: waiting for the spread...photo spread that is...,nailbone, 04:32 PM, 04-12-07
    - RE: waiting for the spread...photo spread that is...,curveball, 02:55 PM, 04-13-07
the producers DID encourage the skin,priestdi, 05:39 PM, 04-14-07

Messages in this discussion

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by Glow on 02-23-07 at 12:48 PM

oh boy. *rolls eyes*

Clear eyes, full hearts, can't lose

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by mrc on 02-23-07 at 02:13 PM

Hey, I'm less enthused (meaning my bedroom wall isn't covered in Haley posters). I don't think she'll last, and I don't like her singing style as much as I do Kat's.
But if she sings barefoot . . .
Slice & Dice Chop Shop 2004

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by Glow on 02-23-07 at 03:29 PM

you mean barefoot and on her knees

Clear eyes, full hearts, can't lose

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by mrc on 02-23-07 at 03:36 PM

That, too.
Ferociously purrfected by thndrkttn

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by Angelflutter on 04-02-07 at 07:09 PM

<<<<<<<< Giggle >>>>>>>>>

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by agman on 04-02-07 at 07:21 PM

Hey she is really hot!

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 04-04-07 at 11:04 AM

She is such a tease to you guys. lol Oh well to each there own.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by nailbone on 04-04-07 at 02:14 PM

You say that like it's a bad thing.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 04-04-07 at 02:34 PM

I guess if you like it is ok.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by agman on 04-04-07 at 02:50 PM

>I guess if you like it
>is ok.
Bob, If Haley wanted to tease me, she has my permission!. She's hot! I don't think it would be a bad thing at all lmao!

A snidget original

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 04-04-07 at 03:36 PM

go for it dude.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by agman on 04-04-07 at 02:52 PM

>You say that like it's
>a bad thing.
>
I happen to think it's a GOOD thing.

A snidget original

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 04-04-07 at 03:37 PM

Have fun with that!

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by nailbone on 02-23-07 at 04:20 PM

Once again, we think alike. She's my pick, too. Hopefully, she'll grow and get better like Kat did.
AND she's a Texan, from San Antonio, one of my fave place.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by brvnkrz on 02-24-07 at 12:13 PM

How dare you cheat on our beloved Kat. Hrmph.
One nation, under Romber

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by mrc on 02-24-07 at 03:51 PM

I'm not cheating--I'm just . . . interested.
What is Phil's golf equipment?
Our? Our?!?

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by motormouth on 02-25-07 at 03:48 AM

*rolls eyes*

whatever

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by SilverStar on 02-26-07 at 03:42 PM

My swoony pick is Blake. Luckily for me, I think he'll make it pretty far. Yay!

"Ahem."
Posted by mrc on 03-01-07 at 10:41 AM

This thread is *not* about Blake.
Sigs by Bob about chalk dust. Pretty exciting stuff
mrc<--doesn't hold grudges when peeps call him old.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by mrc on 03-01-07 at 10:38 AM

I might have to retract my new crush. I still think she is smokin', but I'm not sure I liked her attitude last night. She doesn't seem to take criticism well.
Sigs by Bob about chalk dust. Pretty exciting stuff
mrc<--always takes criticism well.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by mrc on 03-08-07 at 03:57 PM

I officially retract my crush. Haley still looks hot, but her voice is average at best and she has a fragile ego. I don't need another one of those.
Sigs by Bob about chalk dust. Pretty exciting stuff

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 03-08-07 at 04:04 PM

She would make a good tour guide at universal studios.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by YankeeDixieDoodle on 03-09-07 at 04:20 PM

Latisha and Melinda may have more meat on their bones, but they've got much better music coming out of their mouths. They're my two top picks. And, Haley's my third. So far!

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bullzeye on 03-08-07 at 06:36 PM

Shocked, surprised and most disappointed with some of the responses in this thread, especially from Boner, whom I recently confided that he could pick my next mistress.
This girl oozes something all right, and it smells like trailer trash.

A birthday present from Tribe

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by nailbone on 03-09-07 at 10:27 AM

True, but she's the best of this bunch. Not much to work with here.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bullzeye on 03-09-07 at 10:54 AM

I suppose that in fairness, I'll have to give you that.

A birthday present from Tribe

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by SherpaDave on 03-09-07 at 05:26 PM

Ewww, ewww, ewww, ewww.
And I did I mention ewww?

"Ok, last night?"
Posted by nailbone on 03-21-07 at 09:00 AM

Wow. H-O-T-T!!!
Can she sing? Yeah.
Is she as good as Melinda, Lakisha, or Jordin? Nah.
But I don't care. She's my eye-candy, and I think she may have figured that angle out, and it'll keep her around for a little while longer.

"RE: Just OK Last Night"
Posted by LisaPles on 03-21-07 at 09:58 AM

Yeah, she's the new Kat alright. Trying to sell her looks but her vocal talent is mediocre. Zzzzzzzz...

"RE: Ok, last night?"
Posted by priestdi on 03-21-07 at 10:02 AM

yeah she suddenly found her niche, her personal ID on the show. first time she actually was memorable for me the next day.
I totally didn't see that coming. so to speak.
I'm a chick, and I found myself admiring her lovely back, and wondering how they had her boobs strapped in place. lol. must be marvelous tape-em-up technology in hollywood these days.

"RE: Ok, last night?"
Posted by nailbone on 03-21-07 at 11:22 AM

and wondering how they had her boobs strapped in place.
More of that pageant experience coming out.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by joannie on 03-22-07 at 03:14 PM

I totally (heart) Haley after her last performance. She has been through the wringer and I'm glad she finally had a great, fun performance. My opinion of her has done a total 360! And I'm glad that Lulu taught Haley how to work the camera to her advantage.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 03-27-07 at 04:47 PM

You can have them both. blah blah blah. I would take Gina or Kellie Picklier any day. Haley and Kat are teases lol Kellie and Gina you figure it out. lol

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by Magnolia_Rocker on 03-28-07 at 08:04 AM

Quick question...how do you know they are teases since all you've seen of them is what is shown on TV?

A Tribe Original!

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 03-28-07 at 10:39 AM

OMG you are so funny. lol

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 03-28-07 at 10:42 AM

They just are to me. I am just telling you I like Kellie and Gina better. OMG I can't beleive you want to disput what turns me on. lol

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by nailbone on 03-28-07 at 02:19 PM

Not a dispute, just asking for clarification.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by Magnolia_Rocker on 03-28-07 at 02:26 PM

Thank you Boner...I just saw his response. Aye, just wanted clarification because to me, calling someone a tease means you have first hand knowledge. Just sayin.

A Tribe Original!

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 03-28-07 at 02:57 PM

LAST EDITED ON 03-28-07 AT 03:08 PM (EST)
LAST EDITED ON 03-28-07 AT 03:02�PM (EST)
You guys are hillarous. Thanks!
You two should be attroneys when you grow up. lol
When I read your comments my side hurt from the laughing. You should go on a sitcom or something.
Are you guys going to be oversesntive and complain that i am bashing too?

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by nailbone on 03-28-07 at 03:31 PM

Are you going to answer the question?

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 03-28-07 at 04:02 PM

.........."you figure it out."

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 03-29-07 at 12:45 PM

lol

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 04-01-07 at 02:15 PM

I guess not.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by LisaPles on 04-04-07 at 03:57 PM

I think it's a shame that Haley dresses like a tart each week in a desperate attempt to get votes when she should really be working as hard on her vocals.
I think that's what the judges were tying to get across when they didn't say much about her singing and just said "you look great" as usual. As a woman, I think that would be insulting. I almost felt bad for her. Maybe she would tone down her look if she had more confidence in her singing ability. I think she is OK, but not any better than I could see at my local high school cabaret.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bob_chester on 04-04-07 at 04:47 PM

She actually looks better in the preview when she is working with the 'Star" prior to her preformance. "tart' is a good work for it.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by YankeeDixieDoodle on 04-05-07 at 06:50 PM

Lisa, you livin' inside my head or something? Your thoughts are mine exactly. Haley's vocal ability is strictly HS follies. Except, she would've been sent home to change clothes first. I suspect, as you do, that the breast exposure is "compensation" for lack of vocal ability. I don't see Melinda exposing hers.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by habman on 04-06-07 at 09:23 AM

. . . but Lakisha exposes her breasts and no one raises an eyebrow.
I am not saying that Haley is a great singer. Clearly she is not. However I found that the judges were extremely rude to her by not even commenting on her vocals.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by bullzeye on 04-06-07 at 11:06 AM

. . . but Lakisha exposes her breasts and no one raises an eyebrow.
IMHO I don't really think Lakisha has a choice in the matter.

A birthday present from Tribe

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by Snidget on 04-07-07 at 08:29 PM

Word!
For some woman the cleavage is visible even in a dress cut pretty modestly. Heck, even in a turtleneck their would be no hiding Lakisha's chest.

"I am returning this otherwise good typing paper to you because someone has printed gibberish all over it and put your name at the top."
- An English Professor

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by prosecutor on 04-07-07 at 08:21 PM

>I found that the judges
>were extremely rude to her
>by not even commenting on
>her vocals.

The reason the judges did not comment on her vocals is that,
Ryan read her a question from a fan about if she is more nervous on stage or waiting for the judges critique. Well, she stupidly answered that Simon this and Simon that as if Simon is the only judge there. Soooooo Paula and Randy dissed her back.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by joannie on 04-07-07 at 09:08 PM

I think Haley has finally found the key to Simon's heart....which is short skirts! (Oh, I forgot! It's a SINGING competition!)
More power to ya, girl!

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by agman on 04-07-07 at 10:14 PM

(Oh, I
>forgot! It's a SINGING
>competition!)
>
>More power to ya, girl!
I hate to admit it but before this season, I actually thought that it was a singing competition! Of course there was also a time when I believed in santa and the Easter Bunny.....

A snidget original

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by Fishercat on 04-08-07 at 00:11 AM

Well, there's no reason to be afraid of the other two. Unless you're Chris Sligh, Paula will never say anything bad and Randy's nothing at this point.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by YankeeDixieDoodle on 04-09-07 at 03:11 PM

LAST EDITED ON 04-09-07 AT 03:17 PM (EST)
LOL

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by agman on 04-09-07 at 03:21 PM

LAST EDITED ON 04-09-07 AT 03:34 PM (EST)
LAST EDITED ON 04-09-07 AT 03:23�PM (EST)
>I find all over-exposed breasts offensive.
>Early in the competition, Lakisha
>showed hardly any cleavage. But,
>since she's started wearing dresses
>made for a B cup,
>her DD's have quit working
>under cover. But, Melinda still
>keeps hers out of sight.
>Even though she's full-figured, too.
>It's Haley who goes out
>of the way for maximum
>exposure.
I think many of the contestants realize that singing is not necessarily the only way they are being judged. Some of them, Haley comes to mind, seem to be looking for some kind of edge. I agree about Lakisha which is a shame for she has an outstanding voice. Sanjaya has his "hair" factor. Eventually, I do believe that the best singers will be left. It's too bad this year seems to be more about gimicks than substance.(IMO of course)In a small way it's sort of like "Survivor", the contestants are doing what they think they need to do to survive another week. unfortunately(or fortunately depending on you point of view) it's not always about improving vocals. I think I probably put everyone to sleep with this by now so I will end it. Take care

A snidget original

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by YankeeDixieDoodle on 04-09-07 at 03:40 PM

I agree. Sanjaya's hair seems to be his gimmick. And, tartiness, Haley's. It seemed to be Kat's, too.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by YankeeDixieDoodle on 04-09-07 at 03:32 PM

I don't care who's exposing their breasts, I'm tired of it. Haley, Lakisha, Paula, whoever. Lakisha's breasts were well covered, earlier in the competition, until she started wearing the long gowns. But the equally endowed Melinda still manages to keep hers under cover. Which makes Haley's breast exposure seem even more deliberate.

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by agman on 04-09-07 at 03:35 PM

>I don't care who's exposing their
>breasts, I'm tired of it.
>Haley, Lakisha, Paula, whoever. Lakisha's
>breasts were well covered, earlier
>in the competition, until she
>started wearing the long gowns.
>But the equally endowed Melinda
>still manages to keep hers
>under cover. Which makes Haley's
>breast exposure seem even more
>deliberate.
I'm sure it's deliberate!

A snidget original

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by YankeeDixieDoodle on 04-11-07 at 01:57 PM

Even Simon knows it's deliberate. Did you catch his comment last night? About her "lack" of clothing? As a compensatory measure? For her lack of talent?

"RE: Haley is my new Kat"
Posted by agman on 04-12-07 at 11:25 AM

>Even Simon knows it's deliberate. Did
>you catch his comment last
>night? About her "lack" of
>clothing? As a compensatory measure?
>For her lack of talent?
Well, you don't need to worry about it anymore because she's gone. I heard that Lakisha is going to start dressing like Haley did! (just kidding)

A snidget original

"Okay, I'll do it if no one else will"
Posted by mrc on 04-12-07 at 03:30 PM

Goodbye (or, should I say, adios), Haley's oobies and legs. It was nice while it lasted.
What is Phil's golf equipment?

"RE: Okay, I'll do it if no one else will"
Posted by nailbone on 04-12-07 at 03:53 PM

*sigh* I'm not ready to say goodbye yet!! It shoulda been Sanjaya!! IT SHOULDA BEEN SANJAYA!!!

Or at least creepy-looking Phil

"RE: Okay, I'll do it if no one else will"
Posted by YankeeDixieDoodle on 04-12-07 at 04:23 PM

At least we'll have the "fun" of seeing him "do" country. I suspect, with his hair gelled back in a mullet, he'll "sing" some breathy love ballad while all those teary-eyed teen-ettes swoon.

"RE: Okay, I'll do it if no one else will"
Posted by agman on 04-12-07 at 04:37 PM

>*sigh* I'm not ready
>to say goodbye yet!!
>It shoulda been Sanjaya!!
>IT SHOULDA BEEN SANJAYA!!!
>
I've been wearing a black arm band all day and taking sh#t from my wife about it Haley was fun to look at!

A snidget original

"waiting for the spread...photo spread that is..."
Posted by curveball on 04-12-07 at 04:06 PM

How long until Hef calls? I just renewed my subscription...

"RE: waiting for the spread...photo spread that is..."
Posted by YankeeDixieDoodle on 04-12-07 at 04:18 PM

I don't Hef'l have a chance to call. I'll be she beats him to it. What an exhibitionist.

"RE: waiting for the spread...photo spread that is..."
Posted by nailbone on 04-12-07 at 04:32 PM

Eh, I've seen MUCH worse.

"RE: waiting for the spread...photo spread that is..."
Posted by curveball on 04-13-07 at 02:55 PM

She's not an exhibitionist, she's actually quite shy. If she was an exhibitionist, she would have "released" photos of her (or someone that looks like her) in various states of undress.
-cb

"the producers DID encourage the skin"
Posted by priestdi on 04-14-07 at 05:39 PM

I was sure of it.
http://www.realitytvworld.com/news/ousted-american-idol-finalist-haley-scarnato-surprised-at-legs-uproar-4999.php

"I thought about the shorts just because it was a more upbeat kind of song and it would be comfortable to wear," said Scarnato, explaining why she decided to bear her legs for the performance. "And just kind of finished the style. We just molded it together... you get so much feedback from everybody and they're kind of like, 'Keep it.'"
................
Idol executive producer Ken Warwick stood-up for Scarnato and the way she was presenting herself and performing prior to her elimination.
"I think she's good looking kid. I think she has a very good voice. I think she was given a really bad rap by Simon earlier," Warwick told reporters during an April 3 conference call. "She's quite a shy girl; that's the problem. She's not one that's in your face all the time. But she's a lovely kid. I love her. She looks great on stage and she has a good voice. I don't care what Simon says."
......................
"I didn't go shorter. I didn't wear less clothes. I just did the same thing," said Scarnato. "I mean I never really changed my look since Hollywood Week. I kind of showed my midriff a little bit and stuff like that. I want to stay true to who I am and it's fun dressing up...
we never saw much of Hollywood week, I bet this is true.