URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID2
Thread Number: 5230
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by dreamerbeliever on 05-12-04 at 07:46 PM
LAST EDITED ON 05-13-04 AT 03:30 AM (EST)

Survivor has donated a few of the props to be auctioned off on Ebay for charity. Included in the items are the Question and Answer lists from episode twelve. The episode that Rupert won and decided the food pecking order. Most of the lists were too blurry to be read and then low and behold the photo of Jenna's could be read. Once I knew the questions and whose name went with which vertical column as the answer, I was able to go back and decipher the others. For some reason the wrong photo of Alicia's list was used, so I don't have hers. Here are the others however.

Jenna's List

1. Who would you trust with your life? Rupert
2. Who uses sex appeal as a weapon? Amber
3. Who is the most honest? Rupert
4. Who would never survivor on their own? Shii Ann
5. Who would you most like to see pose nude in a magazine? Amber
6. Who would you least like to see win? Alicia
7. Who does not deserve to be an all-star? Alicia
8. Who smells the worst? Tom
9. Who is the biggest drama King or Queen? Alicia
10. Who do you hope to never see pose nude in a magazine? Tom
11. Who in the tribe will you still be talking to in ten year? Rob
12. Who has not lived up to their reputation? Tom
13. If you had to choose one Survivor to never see again who would it be? Alicia
14. Who is the most annoying person out here? Alicia
15. Athletically, who has surprised you the most? Rob
16. Who does the most for the tribe? Rupert
17. Who is the most anti-social? Tom
18. Who is the biggest poser? Alicia
19. Who is the biggest cry-baby? Shii Ann
20. Who is under the false assumption they are smart? Alicia
21. Who does the least for the tribe? Shii Ann
22. Who never shuts-up? Rob
23. Who always sees the glass as half-empty? Alicia
24. Who always sees the glass as half-full? Jenna
25. Who would you most like to be stranded on a dessert island with? Amber

Amber's List

1. Who would you trust with your life? Rob
2. Who uses sex appeal as a weapon? Amber
3. Who is the most honest? Rupert
4. Who would never survivor on their own? Shii Ann
5. Who would you most like to see pose nude in a magazine? Alicia
6. Who would you least like to see win? Tom
7. Who does not deserve to be an all-star? Alicia
8. Who smells the worst? Tom
9. Who is the biggest drama King or Queen? Alicia
10. Who do you hope to never see pose nude in a magazine? Rupert
11. Who in the tribe will you still be talking to in ten year? Rob
12. Who has not lived up to their reputation? Jenna
13. If you had to choose one Survivor to never see again who would it be? Alicia
14. Who is the most annoying person out here? Tom
15. Athletically, who has surprised you the most? Rob
16. Who does the most for the tribe? Rupert
17. Who is the most anti-social? Tom
18. Who is the biggest poser? Jenna
19. Who is the biggest cry-baby? Alicia
20. Who is under the false assumption they are smart? Alicia
21. Who does the least for the tribe? Alicia
22. Who never shuts-up? Jenna
23. Who always sees the glass as half-empty? Shii Ann
24. Who always sees the glass as half-full? Jenna
25. Who would you most like to be stranded on a dessert island with? Rob

Rupert's List

1. Who would you trust with your life? Rupert
2. Who uses sex appeal as a weapon? Amber
3. Who is the most honest? Rupert
4. Who would never survivor on their own? Shii Ann
5. Who would you most like to see pose nude in a magazine? Amber
6. Who would you least like to see win? NO CLEAR MARK
7. Who does not deserve to be an all-star? Alicia
8. Who smells the worst? Tom
9. Who is the biggest drama King or Queen? Shii Ann
10. Who do you hope to never see pose nude in a magazine? Tom
11. Who in the tribe will you still be talking to in ten year? Jenna
12. Who has not lived up to their reputation? Alicia
13. If you had to choose one Survivor to never see again who would it be? Alicia
14. Who is the most annoying person out here? Alicia
15. Athletically, who has surprised you the most? Jenna
16. Who does the most for the tribe? Rupert
17. Who is the most anti-social? Alicia
18. Who is the biggest poser? Alicia
19. Who is the biggest cry-baby? Shii Ann - I think but not to clear
20. Who is under the false assumption they are smart? Alicia
21. Who does the least for the tribe? Alicia
22. Who never shuts-up? Jenna
23. Who always sees the glass as half-empty? Shii Ann
24. Who always sees the glass as half-full? Rob
25. Who would you most like to be stranded on a dessert island with? Jenna

Rob's List

1. Who would you trust with your life? Rob
2. Who uses sex appeal as a weapon? Amber
3. Who is the most honest? Rupert
4. Who would never survivor on their own? Shii Ann
5. Who would you most like to see pose nude in a magazine? Amber
6. Who would you least like to see win? Shii Ann
7. Who does not deserve to be an all-star? Shii Ann
8. Who smells the worst? Tom
9. Who is the biggest drama King or Queen? Alicia
10. Who do you hope to never see pose nude in a magazine? Tom
11. Who in the tribe will you still be talking to in ten year? Amber
12. Who has not lived up to their reputation? Jenna
13. If you had to choose one Survivor to never see again who would it be? Shii Ann
14. Who is the most annoying person out here? Shii Ann
15. Athletically, who has surprised you the most? Rob
16. Who does the most for the tribe? Rupert
17. Who is the most anti-social? Shii Ann
18. Who is the biggest poser? Tom
19. Who is the biggest cry-baby? Tom
20. Who is under the false assumption they are smart? Tom
21. Who does the least for the tribe? Shii Ann
22. Who never shuts-up? Shii Ann
23. Who always sees the glass as half-empty? Shii Ann
24. Who always sees the glass as half-full? Rob
25. Who would you most like to be stranded on a dessert island with? Amber

Shii Ann's List

1. Who would you trust with your life? Tom
2. Who uses sex appeal as a weapon? Amber
3. Who is the most honest? Tom
4. Who would never survivor on their own? Amber
5. Who would you most like to see pose nude in a magazine? Alicia
6. Who would you least like to see win? Jenna
7. Who does not deserve to be an all-star? Jenna
8. Who smells the worst? Jenna
9. Who is the biggest drama King or Queen? Alicia
10. Who do you hope to never see pose nude in a magazine? Tom
11. Who in the tribe will you still be talking to in ten year? Amber
12. Who has not lived up to their reputation? Rob
13. If you had to choose one Survivor to never see again who would it be? Jenna
14. Who is the most annoying person out here? Jenna
15. Athletically, who has surprised you the most? Amber
16. Who does the most for the tribe? Rupert
17. Who is the most anti-social? Shii Ann
18. Who is the biggest poser? Jenna
19. Who is the biggest cry-baby? Alicia
20. Who is under the false assumption they are smart? Shii Ann
21. Who does the least for the tribe? Alicia
22. Who never shuts-up? Jenna
23. Who always sees the glass as half-empty? Rob
24. Who always sees the glass as half-full? Jenna
25. Who would you most like to be stranded on a dessert island with? Rupert

Tom's List

1. Who would you trust with your life? Rob
2. Who uses sex appeal as a weapon? Amber
3. Who is the most honest? Tom
4. Who would never survivor on their own? Alicia
5. Who would you most like to see pose nude in a magazine? Amber
6. Who would you least like to see win? Shii Ann
7. Who does not deserve to be an all-star? Shii Ann
8. Who smells the worst? Rupert
9. Who is the biggest drama King or Queen? Alicia
10. Who do you hope to never see pose nude in a magazine? Rupert
11. Who in the tribe will you still be talking to in ten year? Rob
12. Who has not lived up to their reputation? Jenna
13. If you had to choose one Survivor to never see again who would it be? Jenna
14. Who is the most annoying person out here? Jenna
15. Athletically, who has surprised you the most? Rob
16. Who does the most for the tribe? Rupert
17. Who is the most anti-social? Alicia
18. Who is the biggest poser? Alicia
19. Who is the biggest cry-baby? Alicia
20. Who is under the false assumption they are smart? Jenna
21. Who does the least for the tribe? Alicia
22. Who never shuts-up? Jenna
23. Who always sees the glass as half-empty? Alicia
24. Who always sees the glass as half-full? Jenna
25. Who would you most like to be stranded on a dessert island with? Rupert

Table of contents
Messages in this discussion
"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by SouperStar on 05-13-04 at 06:49 AM
GREAT WORK!!
This explains how the Final 5 played out.
Everyone would trust Rob with their life. Rahmbah & Jenna felt Rupert was the most honest. Amber didn't like, trust or want Tom to win.
While we were all waiting for a play for the swing vote, this explains why there never was one. Nobody trusted Tom. Something either happened out there, or before the game that cost Tom his credibility. The Rahbfaddah kept his friends close, but his enemies closer.

HEY LEX!!
It's just a game!
Lex to Ethan -- It's not personal, it's business.
Lex to Jerri -- It's not personal, it's business.
Lex to Rob -- It's personal, bro.

"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by Loree on 05-13-04 at 10:06 AM
I find it interesting that Shii Ann answered this: Who would never survive on their own? Amber. And yet Shii Ann voted for Amber saying she deserved to win for being the best Survivor. Doesn't make sense to me.
"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by Ra_8secs on 05-13-04 at 10:21 AM
Yet another example of Shii-Ann's superb higher-than everyone else's "intelligence."

I am opposed to millionaires, but it would be dangerous to offer me the position. -- Mark Twain

"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by big tom fan on 05-13-04 at 10:49 AM
why would shi ann choose alicia for the person she would most likely see to pose nude?????
"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by Loquatrix on 05-13-04 at 01:46 PM
I find it interesting that Shii Ann answered this: Who would never survive on their own? Amber. And yet Shii Ann voted for Amber saying she deserved to win for being the best Survivor. Doesn't make sense to me.

Disagree. The two aren't mutually exclusive at all.

Clearly, Amber would never survive on her own if left on an uninhabited island for 39 days. She just wouldn't be able to do the pure physical food and shelter and water thing.

However, that's not what the game of Survivor is about. It's about surviving the political machinations of a microcosm of society on that island for 39 days, where other individuals can be relied upon to provide the physical necessities. And that's what Amber did.

Shii Ann's two answers there make complete sense.

"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by gallopingael on 05-13-04 at 11:28 AM
LAST EDITED ON 05-13-04 AT 11:29 AM (EST)

Thanks for posting this and doing all that work, Dream.

> Rupert's List
>6. Who would you least like
>to see win? NO
>CLEAR MARK


Is it just me or if you look at Question 6 on Rupert's list does he in fact have himself down as the answer?

Rupert's List on Ebay

It's ok if it's just me.....

Gallopin' Gael

"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by Brownroach on 05-13-04 at 11:34 AM
Is it just me or if you look at Question 6 on Rupert's list does he in fact have himself down as the answer?

Sure looks like he checked his own box to me.


"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by sittem on 05-13-04 at 12:05 PM
It looks clearly to me like he checked his own name.

I'm guessing he made a slight error reading the question and ommited the word "least".

2002 IceCat Originals, Inc. All rights reserved.

"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by Brownroach on 05-13-04 at 12:09 PM
I think it's funny that Rupert chose Jenna as the person who never shuts up, and then chose her as the person he'd most like to be stranded on a desert island with. AAAAAHHH!


"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by dreamerbeliever on 05-13-04 at 04:16 PM
I was leaning towards putting Rupert down as the answer to question six but I decided to go the neutral route. There are a couple of smudge spots on Rupert's list (hey he's a big sweaty guy) and I figured he probably wouldn't answer himself for that particular question. While it's not out of the realm of possibilities, I thought it was too unlikely. My first inclination however, was Rupert put himself down for that question.

Agreeing with an earlier post, I found it interesting that Tom did receive a number of negative questions. It was surprising that he received a few votes for the anti-social, poser, and not lived up to reputation questions. Big Tom was edited as the loosy goosy type who kept everyone in high spirits. Like Jenna, I could see how his personality might be like nails on a chalkboard after a few weeks of 24/7.

Funniest answer to me had to be Tom's question number eight. The smelliest. Why is it that the smelly person in a room never realizes they are the one who stinks? Do they enjoy their own scent?

"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by Blow by Blow on 05-13-04 at 12:37 PM
That's definitely the most fascinating and compelling check on what was going on in the minds of the survivors. I find it remarkable that they were all so modest and seldom put their own names down.

-BbB

I do more to not work than actual work.

"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by FFantasyFX on 05-13-04 at 11:46 PM
>LAST EDITED ON 05-13-04
>AT 03:30 AM (EST)
>
> Shii Ann's List

>20. Who is under the false
>assumption they are smart?
>Shii Ann


This perhaps explains Shii Ann's vote at the final Tribal Council.

I have to say that of all the answers on the lists, this one cracked me up the most.


"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by westerberg14 on 05-14-04 at 01:28 PM
I was surprised by the number of questions asked... They didn't use all of them in the challenge - right?? Couldn't the arguement be made that the challenge was "fixed" since the producers could pick questions that would allow certain players (hmmm... maybe RUPERT) to advance?? I guess this was the rope-chopping challenge, so maybe this isn't a good example - but wouldn't 10 questions all revealed in order be enough to get them to the end??
"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by FrogPrincess on 05-14-04 at 01:56 PM
They probably didn't have a majority on most of them. The least deserving one was a tie, but they chose that one b/c they knew it would piss Alicia off.

FrogP

"We got an overweight, gay, naked man walking around, and no one seems to let it bother them" :-D

"RE: Episode 12 Q&A Reward Challenge List"
Posted by Brownroach on 05-14-04 at 03:04 PM
Also, they had to have an excess of questions because there was the chance that everyone would pick the wrong answer on at least a few of them, thus stalling the challenge from going forward. For all we know, that could have happened on a couple of questions Jeff asked, and so they got edited out.