I would discount AJ3 right away, because I don't think any of the gals were even remotely on the same level as some of the guys on the first two shows.AJ2 had dudes that were more outrageous looking overall but AJ1 had the most losers. Tattletale Brad from AJ1 gets my vote as the #1 creep and loser. Something tells me that guy is a pervert. Not far behind at #2 is fat Joe from AJ1, who is just plain disgusting. #3 is the guy who sang to Melana and got an orgasm when she gave him a mercy peck on the cheek. Somebody do him a favor and tell him knee high tube socks went out with disco. #4 is David Daskal who croaked yet another lame song to Larissa. Any tool who would humiliate himself with some hideously bad singing automatically gets in the top 5. Then Joe's crew of fat slobs from AJ1 fall in line.
Phuc from AJ2, who may be a loser, doesn't make the list. He is my favorite because he clearly realized from day one that he was in over his head with Larissa and was cool with it.