I would say there was a tie in the first round but when Bo sang vehicle he knocked it out of the park for good securing victory. Carrie hits high octaves I love that about her that puts her in contention with Bo but Bo is a step up and in a league of his own. Instead of everyone judging on the final day which I thought was gravely patronizing I believe they should have been judging on the entirity of the competition which I think what we would have had left then was a very profound reversal of fortune. Bo you deserved the throne don't know what was up with the polling that day. Rock on Bo.

• RE: Song one tie, two definitely to Bo three to Carrie.. Bo wins!,volsfan, 10:22 PM, 05-31-05
• RE: Song one tie, two definitely to Bo three to Carrie.. Bo wins!,anthonyishot93, 07:15 PM, 06-29-05

I totally disagree with you. If you look at the entire season, Carrie had the strongest vocals week end and week out. I was disappointed in Carrie in the finale though...she didn't hit the notes she did during the season.

bo should have won i totally agree bo is the best and we all know it for those of u who like carrie sure she is good but good enough to beat bo? MAYBE but i am still mad about that (bo not winning) and i still can't get over constantine leaving we did have a petition going around for that but it never reached the signatures it needed but we did have alot.