URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID88
Thread Number: 431
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"9/12 Performance Show "
Posted by cycles2k on 09-12-06 at 09:06 PM
Hi Gang, Lets keep discussion about the September 12th peformance show in this thread.
Table of contents
- RE: 9/12 Performance Show ,cycles2k, 09:08 PM, 09-12-06
- Back from the dead is.....,cycles2k, 09:11 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Back from the dead is.....,Glow, 09:43 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Back from the dead is.....,mememi, 02:20 PM, 09-13-06
- *Swoon*,CattyChat, 09:11 PM, 09-12-06
- Toby,cycles2k, 09:21 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Toby,CattyChat, 09:27 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Toby,cycles2k, 09:30 PM, 09-12-06
- Toby,arkiegrl, 09:24 PM, 09-12-06
- Lucas,cycles2k, 09:37 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Lucas -- *Swoon*,CattyChat, 09:41 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Lucas -- *Swoon*,nailbone, 11:21 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Lucas -- *Swoon*,LisaPles, 09:19 AM, 09-13-06
- RE: Lucas -- *Swoon*,mememi, 02:32 PM, 09-13-06
- LuKas,Glow, 09:45 PM, 09-12-06
- Dilana,cycles2k, 09:48 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Dilana,CattyChat, 09:52 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Dilana,Sues, 09:53 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Dilana,nailbone, 11:20 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Dilana,mrreality, 01:19 PM, 09-13-06
- RE: Dilana,mememi, 02:38 PM, 09-13-06
- Magni,cycles2k, 09:57 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Magni,CattyChat, 10:00 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Magni,cheesybread, 10:00 PM, 09-12-06
- Early voting,cycles2k, 10:01 PM, 09-12-06
- Initial Votes,CattyChat, 10:01 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Initial Votes,Sues, 10:14 PM, 09-12-06
- Question,PagongRatEater, 11:50 PM, 09-12-06
- RE: Question,dragonflies, 08:33 AM, 09-13-06
- RE: Question,mememi, 02:46 PM, 09-13-06
- RE: 9/12 Performance Show ,bullzeye, 01:56 PM, 09-13-06
Messages in this discussion
"RE: 9/12 Performance Show "
Posted by cycles2k on 09-12-06 at 09:08 PM
I still think a higher level DAW should create this discussion thread, but the bigwigs are letting me down and my refresh finger grows raw with the repetition.
"Back from the dead is....."
Posted by cycles2k on 09-12-06 at 09:11 PM
Ryan Star. Apparently Glowie got her way. He sang his original (Back of My Car) and wins a Honda CRV.
My opinion: His performance was OK but I think Ryan was capable of better.
My other opinion: I like the CRV more than the Element.
"RE: Back from the dead is....."
Posted by Glow on 09-12-06 at 09:43 PM
Of course, I did. My opinion: I love him. My television is happy. I am happy. His smile is priceless.
I like the CRV better too.
"RE: Back from the dead is....."
Posted by mememi on 09-13-06 at 02:20 PM
I was thinking of you last night, Glow -- how thrilled you must have been to have Ryan back! Not the best performance of his I've seen but I'm sure we will all be seeing/hearing more from him!
"*Swoon*"
Posted by CattyChat on 09-12-06 at 09:11 PM
Love Ryan, love "Back of your car" . . . but why did Dilana have to introduce him ?? Consolation prize is a new car . . . but Ryan's real prize was the huge boost in his fan base as viewers around the world have been introduced to his talent.
"Toby"
Posted by cycles2k on 09-12-06 at 09:21 PM
Toby sings: Karma Police (Radiohead)
I enjoyed it but he seemed a little off key to me. Perhaps my imagination.
Throw It Away (original)
Magni on guitar and Toby stayed on stage. Once again, that song is a hit for Toby.
"RE: Toby"
Posted by CattyChat on 09-12-06 at 09:27 PM
Karma Police was just okay to me, but I am not a Radiohead Fan.Tody's original is my 2nd fave from this season - - - I love the energy, melody, lyrics -- everything. I laughed watching Toby & Magni interact -- the EVS on Magni's head & Magni kneeling & holding the guitar for Toby. The whole performance was awesome.
If Toby doesn't win, Toby & Magni should tour together.
"RE: Toby"
Posted by cycles2k on 09-12-06 at 09:30 PM
I was thinking the same thing about Toby and Magni being great together.
"Toby"
Posted by arkiegrl on 09-12-06 at 09:24 PM
He brings the party.
"Lucas"
Posted by cycles2k on 09-12-06 at 09:37 PM
Fix You (Coldplay)Wow, that was incredible.
Headspin (original) {acoustic}
That too was increadible.
For someone who didn't like Lukas throughout most of the season I just became a total convert. Good chance I will be casting my vote for Lukas tonight.
"RE: Lucas -- *Swoon*"
Posted by CattyChat on 09-12-06 at 09:41 PM
LAST EDITED ON 09-12-06 AT 09:45 PM (EST)P.H.E.N.O.M.E.N.A.L. . . . .
ETA -- Oh, I forgot about my bone to pick with Dave . . . WTF was the shout out to Paula after Lucas' amazing set??? Way to cheapen Lucas' performance, "dude." It should have been all about Lucas . . . does anyone care about a drugged up ho in the audience? I think NOT.
"RE: Lucas -- *Swoon*"
Posted by nailbone on 09-12-06 at 11:21 PM
Is that who that was? I never was quite sure.
"RE: Lucas -- *Swoon*"
Posted by LisaPles on 09-13-06 at 09:19 AM
>WTF was the shout out to
>Paula after Lucas' amazing set???
> Way to cheapen Lucas'
>performance, "dude." It should
>have been all about Lucas.
Yeah, my thoughts exactly. Who gives a crap about Paula Abdul! They probably had to grease the doorways to get her inflated head out of there.
Lucas was amazing! Maybe Dave's huge ego was threatened because the audience goes nuts for him.
"RE: Lucas -- *Swoon*"
Posted by mememi on 09-13-06 at 02:32 PM
I thought the same about Paula - wait until after a commercial break, do a quick shout out then move on, don't take the wind out of Lukas's sails like that!! Though I had a quick laugh when, right after intro'ing Pauls from AI, he talked about how great it was to be involved in a show that allows rockers to showcase their originals (total opposite of Idol!!).
"LuKas"
Posted by Glow on 09-12-06 at 09:45 PM
Lukas brings the pretty.
"Dilana"
Posted by cycles2k on 09-12-06 at 09:48 PM
Roxanne (The Police)Great touch getting the guys to sing backup. Very well done.
Supersoul (original)
I never liked this song before, but I think it sounded great tonight.
Jason made a joke. Who'da thunk?
Dave said he loved Dilana a thousand times more than she thinks he loves her. Who'da thought Dave would say such glowing things about Dilana.
"RE: Dilana"
Posted by CattyChat on 09-12-06 at 09:52 PM
Now THAT's the boy band for me . . . Toby, Lukas & Magni Great harmony & eye candy.Oh, Dilana was there too? I hate to say that I've tuned her out during both her performances, so I guess that's where she has landed in my opinion.
"RE: Dilana"
Posted by Sues on 09-12-06 at 09:53 PM
You know, I hope these four have huge fabulous careers with or without 'Supernova'...they're just awesome...
"RE: Dilana"
Posted by nailbone on 09-12-06 at 11:20 PM
Gotta agree, cycles. I have to give Dilana her props. She looked and sounded great tonight. Scary hot was back, more hot than scary.
"RE: Dilana"
Posted by mrreality on 09-13-06 at 01:19 PM
I really hope that Dilana wins, but sadly I fear that she wouldn't. I do think she is the best singer of the four left. I just don't think that the winner will ever be a girl on this show.
"RE: Dilana"
Posted by mememi on 09-13-06 at 02:38 PM
I was more impressed with her than I've been for several weeks now. I thought she did a great job with "Roxanne," I dunno what Paul was griping about, that was great! I even liked her original way better than the last time. Still not sure I see her with SN but she went up in my estimation.
"Magni"
Posted by cycles2k on 09-12-06 at 09:57 PM
Hush (Deep Purple)I'm sure it sounded fine, but I just didn't enjoy it.
When the Time Comes(original)
I guess this sounded fine too. DW left the room during this song.
Magni is such a great guy and an awesome musician. Too bad he does not move me the way the others did tonight.
I'm guessing that Tommy won't be voting for Magni on the Internet tonight.
"RE: Magni"
Posted by CattyChat on 09-12-06 at 10:00 PM
Hush is a fave of mine & Magni nailed it. That was GREAT!!His original is my #3, after Toby & Lukas, respectively . . . #4 if you add Ryan as my #1 original this season.
"RE: Magni"
Posted by cheesybread on 09-12-06 at 10:00 PM
I don't get the anti-magni-ness. I thought he was awesome tonight. But from Tommy and Jason's comments it's obvious he wont win.
"Early voting"
Posted by cycles2k on 09-12-06 at 10:01 PM
From the most to least popular based on the very early voting:1) Dilana
2) Toby
3) Lukas
4) Magni
"Initial Votes"
Posted by CattyChat on 09-12-06 at 10:01 PM
1. Dilana
2. Toby
3. Lukas
4. Magni (IMO that's just all wrong)
"RE: Initial Votes"
Posted by Sues on 09-12-06 at 10:14 PM
I loved Magni's original...but I think it's too good for Supernova. They love Tobey's which is basically a pop song, catchy, but not intense or deep. Which is perfect for them as I don't think they will be either.I wonder how committed they are since two of them are still with their original bands....
"Question"
Posted by PagongRatEater on 09-12-06 at 11:50 PM
I didn't watch last year, so maybe someone else can shed some light on this. What is the point of the final vote? Is one person eliminated from consideration or does it just provide a final barometer or what.Thanks.
"RE: Question"
Posted by dragonflies on 09-13-06 at 08:33 AM
I did watch last year PRE, and don't remember it like this. There were 3 left. The performed, then INXS eliminated MiG, and then both Marty & JD sang with INXS, and then they picked JD. No bottom 3, although there were only 3.So hypothetically, since there are 4, would the 1 not in the bottom 3 win? as if.
Go Pack!
"RE: Question"
Posted by mememi on 09-13-06 at 02:46 PM
>I didn't watch last year, so
>maybe someone else can shed
>some light on this.
>What is the point of
>the final vote? Is
>one person eliminated from consideration
>or does it just provide
>a final barometer or what.
My understanding is they will have the bottom 2 identified by voting, then SN will eliminate one of those. The remaining 3 will then sing and SN will choose the singer for them.
I think it is different from last year though.
"RE: 9/12 Performance Show "
Posted by bullzeye on 09-13-06 at 01:56 PM
That was a fun night! I know I am late with comments but here goes:I thought Ryan rocked it - easily the best original this season. (And...if you look closely, you can see him say, "This one's for you Glow".)
Loved the interaction between Toby and Lukas but neither really gave a commanding finale performance.
Lukas was phenomenal. Simpy phenomenal. I thought he blew everyone out of the water, until Dilana. Don't love her, but she really showed her stuff last night.
A birthday present from Tribe