LAST EDITED ON 03-29-12 AT 10:15 AM (EST)

Very good night overall. Judges did the standing O way too many times...but overall an entertaining night. Really liked the Elise/P2/Colton trio, too.

Tied for first:

1. Elise -- more of this type of performance, please!

1. Joshua -- I wish you were not so hard on yourself and could enjoy the competition more. You look so unhappy for someone so, so talented! I want to see you in the top 3.

3. Hollie -- I think it was a smart choice of song on a night where people were singing well-known-to-them songs. People know that song and vote for song as much as singer. You also stood out in your trio vs. Jessica and Skylar.

4. P2 -- your enjoyment of singing is infectious and a huge part of your appeal

5. Jessica -- I know she is good but seems sorta robotic to me

6. Skylar -- someone seems to have dimmed her light a bit

7. Colton -- your version on you tube was much better. Good voter appeal to the Christian lite rock vote.

Tied for 8th

8. Deandre -- a little falsetto goes a long way for me and an entire song all falsetto seemed to go on for a long time.

9. Heyjun -- the best I have heard you sing but you are not the talent that the many others in the competition are. Time to go.

• RE: AI 11 Top 9 rankings,zazzy, 10:18 AM, 03-29-12

Great minds think alike ;). See Mrc's thread to do rankings.