URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID44
Thread Number: 3217
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"Top 12...er 11 Rankings Sh/Will go"
Posted by emydi on 03-15-12 at 12:56 PM
1. Obama/Elise-they were born the same year!
2. Joshua- best ever, i'd call that hyperbole but JLo (or Steven or Randy or Seacrest) doesn't know what that means
3. Hollie-very good but not great...Mariah is next I'm sure
4. Phillip-WGW/oGorK good esp for being out of surgery less than a week
5. Skylar-good but what would ghountry sound like?
6. Erika-ok she looked better
7. Heejun-he should have done something upbeat and VFTW worthy
8. DeAndre-a duet omh he needed to flip the hair
9. Shannon-I guess Celine is next for her
10. Jessica-omh not good
11. Colton-White Lion too funny
12. EPEP-did they really have to air that, really? Like school on Saturday.....no class

Should be B3 Colton Jessica Shannon
Will be B3 Shannon Deandre Erika
Should go Colton
Will go no one

The timing doesn't work if they lose someone here unless they use the save and only drop 1 singer the week after. I think they'll save everyone tonite

Table of contents
Messages in this discussion
"RE: Top 12...er 11 Rankings Sh/Will go"
Posted by mrc on 03-15-12 at 02:53 PM
Only saw half, so truncated rankings:

1. Elise--Still not the sparkle from before, but the best I saw.
2. Phillip--Good but restrained.
3. Jessica--Good at times, not great at others.
4. Colton--Weird.
5. Heejun--Like him, but notice that Jimmy and will.i.am didn't critique his music.
6. DeAndre--Please go away.
7. Shannon--Likable young woman, but she's outclassed singing-wise.

A Slice of Manga

"RE: Top 12...er 11 Rankings Sh/Will go"
Posted by zazzy on 03-15-12 at 04:35 PM
1) I think that *surprise!* everyone makes the tour like last year.

2) I also predict that they won't boot anyone but will add this week's and next week's votes together to get the boot.

3) They'll still show us bottom 4, perhaps even 6 again, and of course bottom 2, the most in jeopardy.

Bottom 2 guys: HeyJun, Deandre
Bottom 2 girls: Erica, Elise

This week's bottom 2 guy and girl: Deandre and Erica

"RE: Top 12...er 11 Rankings Sh/Will go"
Posted by csnumber23 on 03-15-12 at 06:22 PM
Too bad for Jermaine, he had a good chance to make the tour.

#1 - Colton - I actually like White Lion and enjoyed this

#2 - Joshua - Really good

#3 - Phillip - Good

#4 - Jessica - This was my fav performance by her, go figure.

#5 - Skyler - solid

#6 - Elise - Not great but a lot better

#7 - Holly - She is consistent but is getting boring

#8 - Erika - She doesn't stand out

#9 - Shannon - so-so

#10 - Deandre - not great

#11 - Heejun - Horrible


Should go

Heejun - gone
Deandre - one more week
Shannon - survives


Will go - if anyone

Erika - gone because she doesn't stand out
Heejun - tortures us another week
Deandre - survives