I actually thought Ty was probably the most consistent throughout his routine this week. But Josh is very good at maintaining some type of theme throughout his routines. I would have to put them in the following order.

Tie between Josh and Ty

Chris at a close third - he started out slow but the meep meep at the end brought it home. I wasn't overly impressed with the whole cosket routine.

Michele and granted I didn't hear her whole routine but I just dont see her up the remaining three's level.

I only wish we could vote for who we want to leave instead of voting for our favorite. I would cast my 5 anti-votes for Michele and be happy.

Michele - Airline jokes? AIRLINE JOKES? If that is bringing her best material, then she should just turn around at baggage check and go back to Staten Island.

Ty - Ty was a little uneven material-wise, but he does have a nice delivery and he actually has some fresh ideas.

Josh - Josh is just one of those guys you automatically like when you see him. He needs to stretch a little bit and not do his whole 5 minutes on his disability. I will say, the joke about his coach having the nerve to put him on the disabled list made me laugh out loud.

Chris - I thought his routine was very original. The Coskets idea was hilarious and then when he spun it into the worst case scenario shopping location - that was excellent use of material. Baby seats on the condom aisle - great stuff.

I would agree with the assessment that they all were fairly even in their performances last night. I liked Chris' "cosket" bit also. My hubby and I got a kick out of Josh's drunk, cerbal palsey, Scottish accent bit. (probably because my hubby is part Scotch/Irish)

Tough call for me on who should go. I like Josh and Chris the best overall so I'm leaning towards Michelle.

I though Roz was the right choice to go out of the five. I like her but if people voted on just her performance, she really was lacking and her yelling for the whole set was very wearing.

Hey, Hey! It's a Tribephyl creation!

I thought Michelle did good last night. But I think she is going home.

Ty was the best IMO - but Josh def has the popularity vote!

I think Michelle will probably wind up going home too.

I think it's a shame because:

1) she's the only woman left, which means, if she goes, yet another man will win.

2) she is the only one who had to fight the hardest to get this far! She was challenged every.single.week., yet beat out all those other comics!

3) she had to use a lot of different material all those weeks and still managed to keep it fresh. The other three did not.

4) I think she was good last night too.

I thought Michelle was funny and hope she squeaks by again. She always has such a surprised look on her face when they announce that she's moving on. Josh relied too much on his disability which was funny, but has gotten old over the weeks. Chris' bit about Costco was hilarious and I just plain don't like Ty's material.