By Thursday 3/3 we'll have our top 13--10 thru voting (5M 5F) and 3 wildcards

Who do you think WILL go through and Who do you think SHOULD go through Make sure to mark who you think will be the Wildcards

Ashton Jones
Haley Reinhart
Julie Zorilla
Karen Rodriguez
Kendra Chantelle Campbell
Lauren Alaina Suddeth
Lauren Turner
Naima Adedap
Pia Toscano
Rachel Zevita
Ta-Tynisa Wilson
Thia Megia

Brett Lowenstern
Casey Abrams
Clint Jun Gamboa
Jacob Lusk
James Durbin
Jordan Dorsey
Jovany Barreto
Paul McDonald
Robbie Rosen
Scotty McCreery
Stefano Langone
Tim Halprin

• RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,emydi, 11:08 AM, 02-25-11
  • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,emydi, 10:57 AM, 03-02-11
• RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,Tummy, 01:15 PM, 02-25-11
  • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,csnumber23, 03:54 AM, 02-26-11
• RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,Belle Book, 01:29 PM, 02-26-11
  • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,Belle Book, 05:29 PM, 03-03-11
• RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,Snidget, 09:41 PM, 02-26-11
• RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,Corvis, 01:33 AM, 02-28-11
  • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,Corvis, 07:05 PM, 03-02-11
• Can Do Before and After ,emydi, 12:02 PM, 02-28-11
  • RE: Can Do Before and After ,cahaya, 09:00 PM, 03-01-11
    • 'After' picks,cahaya, 04:22 PM, 03-02-11
• RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,cahaya, 04:43 PM, 03-02-11
  • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,emydi, 11:17 AM, 03-03-11
  • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,Corvis, 11:41 AM, 03-03-11
    • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup ,emydi, 12:53 PM, 03-03-11
• RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup RESULTS,emydi, 12:11 PM, 03-04-11
  • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup RESULTS,cahaya, 12:28 PM, 03-04-11
  • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup RESULTS,Belle Book, 09:54 PM, 03-04-11
    • RE: AI 10 PTTE warmup RESULTS,Tummy, 09:51 AM, 03-05-11

LAST EDITED ON 02-28-11 AT 12:02 PM (EST)

BEFORE SEEING THE PERFORMANCES

WILL GO THROUGH

Haley Reinhart WC
Julie Zorilla
Karen Rodriguez
Lauren Alaina Suddeth
Naima Adedap
Rachel Zevita

Brett Lowenstern WC
Casey Abrams
Jacob Lusk
James Durbin
Jordan Dorsey WC
Paul McDonald
Scotty McCreery

SHOULD GO THROUGH

Julie Zorilla
Karen Rodriguez
Lauren Turner WC
Naima Adedap
Pia Toscano
Rachel Zevita

Brett Lowenstern
Casey Abrams
Jacob Lusk
Jordan Dorsey WC
Jovany Barreto
Paul McDonald
Scotty McCreery WC

LAST EDITED ON 03-03-11 AT 11:14 AM (EST)

Guys POST PERFORMANCE

Will go through

Scotty
Casey
James
Jacob
Brett or Paul the other goes on WC
Tim WC JLo

Should go Through

Brett
James
Casey
Jacob
Scotty
Jordan WC!

Gals Post peformance

Will go through

Pia
Lauren Alaina
Thia
Julie
Naima
Karen WC

Should go through

Rachel WC!
Karen
Lauren Turner
Naima
Thia
Pia

Be back tomorrow with gals

Will Go Thru

Lauren Alaina
Thia Megia
Karen Rodriguez
Haley Reinhart
Naima Adedap
Julie Zorilla - WC

Brett Lowenstern
Casey Abrams - WC
Tim Halprin - WC
Jacob Lusk
Clint Jun Gamboa
Scotty McCreery
James Durbin

Should Go -

Lauren Alaina
Thia Megia
Karen Rodriguez
Pia Toscano
Naima Adedap
Julie Zorilla - WC

Brett Lowenstern
Casey Abrams
Tim Halprin - WC
Jacob Lusk
James Durbin
Scotty McCreery
Paul McDonald - WC

My will go and should are the same for now until I see them live

Casey
James
Scotty
Jacob
Clint
Paul WC
Tim WC

Lauren A
Haley
Julie
Rachel
Pia
Ashton WC

LAST EDITED ON 02-27-11 AT 01:42 PM (EST)

Should go through:

Ashton Jones,
Julie Zorilla,
Karen Rodriguez (WC),
Lauren Alaina Suddeth,
Naima Adepap,
Pia Toscano (WC)
& Thia Megia!

Casey Abrams,
James Durbin,
Paul McDonald,
Robbie Rosen (WC),
Scotty McCreery
& Jacob Lusk.

Will go through:

Ashton,
Julie (WC),
Karen (WC),
Lauren,
Naima,
Pia &
Thia!

Casey,
Jacob,
James,
Scotty,
Stefano (WC)
& Paul.

The guys that should go through, after the performances:

1. Jacob,
2. James,
3. Casey,
4. Scotty,
5. Stefano

with Paul and Clint as wildcards.

The girls that should go through, after the performances:

1. Pia,
2. Thia,
3. Lauren A.,
4. Lauren T.,
5. Ashthon

& Naima as the Wildcard.

The guys who will go through:

1. Casey,
2. Jacob,
3. James,
4. Paul &
5. Scotty

with either Stefano or Brett as the wildcard.

The girls who will go through:

1. Pia,
2. Thia,
3. Lauren A.,
4. Karen,
5. Naima

with Lauren T. as a wildcard. If there are two girls as Wildcards, then Ashthon will be a second Wildcard.

Should

Ashthon
Julie
Lauren T
Naima
Rachel

Casey
Jacob
Jordan
Robbie
Tim

Wild Cards
Pia
Karen
Paul

Will

Ashthon
Haley
Lauren A
Rachel
Thia

Brett
Casey
Jacob
James
Paul
Scotty

Wild Cards
Julie
Naima
Robbie

Just one list - will and should:

Brett Lowenstern
Casey Abrams
Jacob Lusk
James Durbin
Paul McDonald

Julie Zorilla
Karen Rodriguez
Lauren Turner
Pia Toscano
Rachel Zevita

Wild cards:
Thia Megia
Tim Halprin
Clint Jun Gamboa

Making a change since Scotty is the only country singer and he'll get those fans voting for him:

Brett Lowenstern
Scotty McCreery
Casey Abrams
Jacob Lusk
James Durbin
Paul McDonald

Julie Zorilla
Karen Rodriguez
Lauren Turner
Pia Toscano
Rachel Zevita

Wild cards:
Thia Megia
Tim Halprin
Brett Lowenstern

The judges will keep Brett in the competition.

You can make new lists...just reply to your first list with AFTER they perform lists. I'll be curious to see how close I came without the performances.

Thanks!

I'd like to see them one more time around before making any picks. I'll do a post after Wednesday night's performances before Thursday's results.

LAST EDITED ON 03-03-11 AT 12:22 PM (EST)

Long list!

----

Guys, should stay

1. James Durbin
2. Jacob Lusk
3. Casey Abrams
4. Scotty McCreery
5. Jovany Barreto
6. Stefano Langone (it was a toss-up here between Stafano, Brett and Robbie, and one, maybe two, will likely be the wildcard)

Guys, should go

7. Brett Loewenstern (toss-up for #6)
8. Robbie Rosen (toss-up for #6)
9. Clint Jun Gamboa
10. Paul McDonald
11. Tim Halperin
12. Jordan Dorsey

Guys, will stay

1. Casey Abrams
2. James Durbin
3. Scotty McCreery
4. Paul McDonald (icky)
5. Jacob Lusk
6. Brett Loewenstern (WC, on the bubble, could be Stafano instead)

Guys, will go

7. Stefano Langone (might get the judge's WC call over Brett or a second WC gal - have to hear the gals first)
8. Tim Halperin (very likely out, no WC)
9. Clint Jun Gamboa (yay! we're rid of him! let's stay rid of him, no WC!)
10. Robbie Rosen (too much of a puppy)
11. Jovany Baretto (alas! I like this guy)
12. Jordan Dorsey (even VFTW couldn't hope to save this guy)

----

Gals, should stay

1. Pia Toscano
2. Thia Megia
3. Lauren Alaina
4. Karen Rodriguez
5. Naima Adedapo
6. Lauren Turner

Gals, should go

7. Ashthon Jones (possible WC)
8. Kendra Chantelle
9. Julie Zorrilla
10. Rachel Zevita
11. Haley Reinhart
12. Ta-Tynisa Wilson

Gals, will stay

1. Pia Toscano
2. Thia Megia
3. Lauren Alaina
4. Lauren Turner
5. Karen Rodriguez (tie with Naima, WC if Naima is voted in)
6. Naima Adedapo (WC)

Gals, will go

7. Ashthon Jones (WC if 3 WC's are handed out)
8. Haley Reinhart (the judges better not blow a WC on this gal)
9. Kendra Chantelle
10. Julie Zorrilla (alas, no WC save for this gal)
11. Rachel Zevita
12. Ta-Tynisa Wilson

By Thursday 3/3 we'll have our top 13--10 thru voting (5M 5F) and 3 wildcards.

Whoops! Looks like a twist in the format. According to Joes Place:

Tomorrow American Idol names the top 10 that WE put through with our votes. HOWEVER, they will NOT be naming any Wild cards during this Thursdays show. Instead, the 14 contestants that were not put through with the votes, will ALL come back to sing next Wednesday (March 9th) to earn a spot as a Wild Card. Then, on Thursday (March 10th), the judges will name TWO (YES TWO) Wild cards to round out the top 12. So, if the judges name the two WC’s then, American will not be voting at all next week, and from the sounds of it we will have a 90 minute show with the contestants that we didn’t care about enough to vote through. However, what IF one of the Wild cards is an “America’s Choice” (Clay Aiken was an America’s Choice Wild Card). The America’s Choice WC, is just speculation at this point.

Also posted this in the ECST as part of a reply to your post there, but thought it would get lost in the shuffle there and reposted it here in reply to format comment up top.