ar you happy with the top 12

• RE: top 12,Divagurl23, 11:35 PM, 03-09-05
  • RE: top 12,seahorse, 00:56 AM, 03-10-05
    • RE: top 12,Wheezy, 03:38 PM, 03-10-05
      • RE: top 12,seahorse, 08:29 AM, 03-11-05
  • RE: top 12,geekboy, 02:21 PM, 03-11-05
• RE: top 12,dragonflies, 11:17 AM, 03-10-05
  • RE: top 12,DearAbby, 01:24 PM, 03-10-05
• RE: top 12,JOSHIDOL, 11:32 AM, 03-10-05
• RE: top 12,nailbone, 12:03 PM, 03-10-05
  • RE: Carrie,niteowl, 06:52 PM, 03-10-05
• I'll miss Nikko,lovwigglesworth, 01:33 PM, 03-10-05
• RE: top 12,Ricky, 03:34 PM, 03-10-05
  • RE: top 12,opinionated, 09:33 PM, 03-10-05
• RE: top 12,shedevil, 09:59 PM, 03-10-05
• RE: top 12,Roo, 10:48 AM, 03-11-05
• RE: top 12,geekboy, 02:18 PM, 03-11-05
• RE: top 12,callalilly3000, 07:44 PM, 03-11-05
• RE: top 12,batts, 04:03 AM, 03-12-05
• RE: top 12,TARugh, 07:30 PM, 03-16-05
  • RE: top 12,brytigerca, 07:38 PM, 03-16-05
    • RE: top 12,batts, 08:13 PM, 03-16-05

No, I hated Ruben and I hated the fact that he was placed in the top 12 on Season 2, BUT I honestly didn't think that he would win!

Now, I feel the same way about Scott. I don't care for the way that he looks, I don't think that he should be in the top 12.. and If he wins I will never watch the show again..

As for the girls, I am happy that Makalah (SP?) went through, I think that she will go pretty far.

And I like miss underwood the country singer, I think that she will also go far..
BUT I HATE Jessica, same goes for scott, She looks like a 37 year old hairdresser and a single mother of 2.
She is not an Idol, Doesn't even come close to being one.

I think that Amanda from Nevada should have went through.. can we say HOT!?!?!

What is up with Simon getting onto the pudgy/fat chicks, and not the Rubens, and Scotts of the competetion?!?!?!?!

It's a conspiracy, and I believe that the show is "guided" down a path of "rigged-dom".

It's a singing contest, not how you look. I do realize that it is tougher for a female who is overweight and not good looking than for a guy in the same boat, but let's face it, we are doing the voting, and we vote for reasons other than who sings the best.

I definitely don't think the voting is rigged. The producers have too much to lose to attempt to rig the vote. As long as the ratings stay high they are thrilled.

Handcrafted by RollDdice

It's not strictly a singing contest. Image is a part of it. Looking comfortable, being able to move/dance, capturing your audience, dressing the part and looking the part all fall into that category. A singer will go farther if he is aesthetic, pleasing to the eye.

Scott seems to be working on that. He still looks like he'd kill ya before he'd lend ya a dime, though.

If it didn't have to be 6 men, 6 women, I would have loved to see Mikayla (sp) out of there and Nico in.

Wheeze

Wheeze * Everything In Between

LAST EDITED ON 03-11-05 AT 08:29 AM (EST)

What kind of image does Ruben and Clay have. Dancing abilities, easy on the eyes, looking like an american idol - I don't think so. Those rules unfortunately only apply to women.

The only criteria to being an AI is building a huge fan base and having a good voice.

Handcrafted by RollDdice

The claims of a conspiracy each season is getting very old. If there really was a conspiracy or vote rigging, i think it would have been exposed by now.

This is MILLIONS AND MILLIONS of viewers voting. The tastes are all going to be different, and just because someone you liked didn't get in does not immediately mean a conspiracy.

The results are based upon the tastes, ages, intelligence, common sense, etc of the voting public. Think that through for a bit.

geekboy

I agree about the voting being rigged to a degree
IMHO, Amanda should have made it instead of Mikala, and Nikko should have made it instead of Anthony or Scott

I don't know about the votes being rigged, but I agree that Amanda and Nikko should have made top 12 instead.

My only complaints for the Top 12 were Mikalah getting in and Nikko not getting in. I think Anthony, Constantine or Mario could have gone in his place. However, think of last season the controversy over the so called "3-Divas". I have no doubt Fox is looking for a battle of the "Rockers". Also, watch the drama they will unfold when one week you will see Constantine and Bo in the Bottom 3. Its all for ratings. I think Mikalah made it to keep the young kids (remember Jasmine) voting. Believe me, I am sure once they moved into that house she will be annoying the heck out of the rest of the people. Her Mother seems to be as annoying as he is and becasue of her age, will be moving in too.
Good Top 12 but a guy is going to win this year. So far, the best is Anwar but since we have Ruben, they will probably fix it so that Mario wins.

More or less. I don't like seeing Mikalah in the finals, because I think some others are more talented. But the judges evidently see (and hear) something I don't because they always gave her good comments.

Other than that, I can live with the rest. Bo, Anwar, Nadia and Carrie are my top four. The rest are just "eh" for me.


New from Sigs by Syren!!

I think Carrie definitely has a great voice, but what happened to her personality? Now that they're top 12 do they get help with song choice? She really got a little boring...

Other than Nikko, I basicaly agree with the top 12. Nikko is better than at least three other guys (Anthony, Scott, and Constantine) that made it in. And better than most all of the females as well. But I do not think any of the guys that got in are bad singers, and do not think Nikko was good enough to win, so I suppose can live with it.
I have come to terms with the fact that Mikalah will be in this for a little longer even though my ears hear her as not a good singer. So as long as Janay, the other "un"-good singer, did not get into the finals, there won't be too much to cringe at. There are only three females (Jessica, Nadia, and Carrie) that I believe will even be able to compete with the males down the road, so as long as those three made it, the rest are about the same talent-level wise.
Don't know if all that made sense but the short answer is; Yes, basically, I am happy with the final 12.

I think Nikko should have made it in instead on Consty. The girls I'm happy with.

In the end, those of us that walk away winning, win more than just a loss - Audrey, Apprentice loser

Agree with you about the guys--Nikko instead of Constantine, but disagree on the girls--think it should've been Amanda instead of Mikalah.

I'm not looking forward to enduring Mikalah's voice in the coming weeks. I'm pulling for a Leah LaBelle--instant boot!!!

LAST EDITED ON 03-10-05 AT 10:00 PM (EST)

I am happy with all of them except for Mikalah.I hope Mikalah is the first to go also.

I'm glad that Janay and Travis are out. I could do without Mikalah and Constantine, though. They both have charisma, but IMO the talent isn't there to back it up.

Handcrafted by RollDdice