So will the voters vote for the girls because we have been told over and over it is a girls year? Or will the voters make us have yet another all boy finale no matter what the judges tell us.

Who do you think should go this week if only America had any sense/taste like you do, and who will they send home for who knows what they were thinking reasons.

We usually have a bottom 3 with one going home, but who knows if they will keep to the script

Should Go

Tim
Andrew (goes home)
Lee

Tim at least was a bit amusing, Lee, I just don't get the appeal but I think he will get a lot of voters and gosh I'm tired of Andrew already.

Will Go
Paige (goes home)
Andrew
Aaron

Paige did well, but won't get enough sympathy votes to make up for the "she shouldn't be in the top 12" feeling. Andrew may have run out of steam and I think Katie will take the tween vote away from Aaron.

• RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,Estee, 07:06 AM, 03-17-10
  • RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,nailbone, 01:44 PM, 03-17-10
    • RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,Estee, 02:41 PM, 03-17-10
• RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,geekboy, 07:17 AM, 03-17-10
  • RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,csnumber23, 07:31 AM, 03-17-10
• RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,emydi, 10:01 AM, 03-17-10
  • RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,Snidget, 04:07 PM, 03-17-10
• RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,tdfrankl, 10:43 AM, 03-17-10
• RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,mrc, 11:41 AM, 03-17-10
  • RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,Estee, 12:52 PM, 03-17-10
• RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,zazzy, 02:40 PM, 03-17-10
• RE: AI9 Top 12 Should Go/Will Go,Belle Book, 04:08 PM, 03-17-10

Should be:

Lacey
Tim
Andrew

Any of the three could leave and it would relieve some of the pain. All three at once could be a workable twist. We could even bump that up to eight.

Probably getting:

Paige
Lacey
Didi

For some reason, I think we're starting with the shocker vote: Paige gets the sickness boost, Lacey pulls out her religion at the right time, and Didi goes home on the stronger performance. Vote For The Somewhat Less Than Mediocre may not be an organized faction, but they've still got all the power.

For some reason, I think we're starting with the shocker vote:

I'd call that ANOTHER shocker vote, what with Lilly going home last week.

Most of last week was shockers, or at least 75% mild surprise... 'kay, I should have said 'starting the Top 12': point taken. This just feels like a weird season -- possibly all the way to the end.

'course, if it's mega-weird, Andrew wins.

Based on my rankings,

Paige
Lacey
Tim (SHOULD go)

But I think Tim will be safe for another week or two.

Based on the other rankings which put Andrew at the bottom (which I don't understand)

Paige
Lacey (Will go)
Andrew

geekboy

"I think what Randy Travis was trying to say was 'What the hell was that?!'" - S. Cowell

I don't understand Andrew being in the bottom either, I thought he was the best of the night. I saw a different side to him and thought he was good.

I'm a huge Stones fan so this week I am a little more critical. There were only a few that I liked and a few that I could tell were Stones songs.

Should be bottom 3

Tim Urban (goes home)
Paige Miles
Lacey Brown

Will be bottom 3

Paige Miles (goes home)
Aaron Kelly
Andrew Garcia

Should

Andrew should go
Didi
Lee (smidge I thought I was the only one!)

Will

Paige
Lacey Will go unless Gokey's faithers start voting for her
Andrew cd be him too

I'm glad I'm not alone in the just don't get Lee bench.

Should:

Andrew (goes home)- he bores me more and more each week
Katie - who keeps voting for her?! :/
Tim

Will:

Andrew (goes home)
Aaron
Lacey/Paige... either could easily be b3

Should:
Lacey
Paige
Aaron

Will:
Paige (buh-bye)
Lacey
Andrew

Lucky post!

Should go:

Andrew
Lacey
Aaron--boot

Will go:

Tim
Andrew
Lacey --- boot

Frankly, if it's Paige, Katie, Lacey, Andrew, or Aaron, that's fine. Heck, throw Tim on the pile, too, even though he's showing some growth.

Not ok to be booted: Crystal, Casey, Lee, Siobhan, Michael, & Didi-but Didi is close to slipping into the ok to be booted pile.

Should be in the Bottom 3:

Lacey Brown,
Andrew Garcia
and Tim Urban.

Will be in the Bottom 3:

Paige Miles,
Andrew
and Lacey.

Should go home:

Tim. He's the worst of all of them but the teenyboppers will save him from the Bottom 3.

Will go home:

Andrew. He peaked too soon and it's time for him to go.