I have watched American Idol from the first time they were on. I have enjoyed it, or most of it. I record it and then watch it later. In all the years I have only kept one song by one singer. That was Kady Malloy when she sang Groovy kind of love. I had heard it before but never like that. I have kept that and listen to it over and over. I like the very thing that Simon and the other judges didn't like. She could have sung louder but she held back and it was incredible. The judges are responsible for a lot of good performers being voted off. I am sure they are sorry many times for thoughtless comments that cause viewers not to vote for the singers. I hope Kady already has a record contract. I was away and didn't see her get voted off. I wish you all the luck in the world Kady you have a fantastic voice. You were not there to do an impression of Britney but to sing in your own voice and it is amazing. You have a lot of talent and the judges let you down badly.

• RE: Best singer ever,nailbone, 06:30 PM, 04-13-08
  • RE: Best singer ever,zazzy, 06:21 PM, 04-15-08
• RE: Best singer ever,superforger, 08:15 PM, 04-16-08
• RE: Best singer ever,Tahj, 02:10 PM, 04-17-08

Her problem was that she DID do an impression of Britney, and couldn't overcome that idea in the judges minds.

One of her problems is they had other girls they wanted to pimp--Carly and Kristy Lee come to mind--just look at the video support they got versus Kady or Alaina.

I think it is very hard to judge who is the best singer. But, personally, for this season, I like Asia'h Epperson. It is a shame she was voted out so early.

I'll never forget John "Howdy Doody" Stevens version of "King of the Road." Magical.

It's a Tribe!