I am beginning to think Scott has a problem with his eyesight. I missed the first few episodes so I did not have the pleasure of seeing Scott & Melanie room together. I know he's probably trying to stay in his own age group but Melanie seems a little off to me & homely. Then Melanie leaves- on to Toni. Whoa! Scott, was it either hook up with Toni or she kicks you A$$? Were you blackmailed? Just playing, Holly is his best mate so far IMO- pretty, upbeat & honest...glad he's seen the light, let's hope he doesn't return to the expiring Melaine who is breifly visiting...

• RE: Scott's taste in women,sbeck, 02:24 PM, 09-04-03
• RE: Scott's taste in women,Chrissy gal, 07:24 PM, 09-04-03
  • Thanks for the info,Crazy4Jason, 09:16 AM, 09-05-03
    • RE: Thanks for the info,Chrissy gal, 08:28 PM, 09-05-03
• RE: Scott's taste in women,SurvivinDawg, 12:52 PM, 09-05-03
  • RE: Scott's taste in women,sbeck, 01:24 PM, 09-05-03
    • RE: Scott's taste in women,ugibugi, 01:35 AM, 09-07-03
• RE: Scott's taste in women,DESTINYx69, 04:48 PM, 09-10-03

I have to agree with you. Melanie was just plain weird when she returned - acting all buddy-buddy when she was there only a week, and half the guys and girls said she was too old (ha!) anyway. But based on looks and strategy, Scott would do well to stick with Holly. 'Cause if he tries to lobby for Melanie's return and Holly gets wind of it, she will be able to get Scott kicked off, that's for sure.

I haven't been totally involved in this show from the beginning, but here is my memory of the first few episodes:

Week 1: Charla did not have a roommate. The roommates were - Scott/Melanie, Andon/Toni, Beau/Amanda, Zach/Amy, Alex/Kristen. Andon and Kristen did not get along. Zach was unhappy that Amy was the only girl to pick him, then Zach and Amy had sex on the first night.

Week 2: Charla picked Scott and nobody else could pick him because "no one can leave paradise without having a roommate". I think the others all stayed together, so Melanie was gone. Dave was the new guy. I don't remember who he chose for his roommate, but it wasn't Charla. Amanda and Beau were fighting and Amanda was getting friendly with Alex.

Week 3: They were told that they had to choose different roommates. Dave went to Charla; Alex, Zach & Scott went to Toni; Andon and Beau went to Amy; nobody chose Amanda or Kristen. Toni chose Alex, Amy chose Beau, Zach and Andon went to Amanda and, Scott went to Kristen. Amanda chose Zach and Andon was out. Kavita was the new person and she chose Zach as a roommate (this was after Amanda and Zach got cozy and kissed). Kavita and Zach made out, then they decided they didn't like eachother.

Week 4: After Alex threw up from kissing Toni, he wanted to go back to Kristen. So Toni picked Scott (I think Kavita also picked Scott). Kavita is sent packing.

My point in all of this? Scott and Melanie were only roommates for a week, he also roomed with Charla and Kristen, and Scott didn't room with Toni until the 4th week.

If I have made any mistakes in my post, please let me know.

Chrissy gal

"Never underestimate the potential psychosis of a reality show contestant." managerr

Thanks Chrissy gal! We missed the first two episoeds, that helped me out in seeing how all of the drama between the guests started. Didn't know Melanie was there for only week #1! I wonder why Scott seems so buddybuddy with Melanie since her return, Holly seems so much more appealing- to each their own I gusee. Have a great weekend!

I think the answer to your question is in SurvivinDawg's post below.

I think Scott's comment to Holly, "I could rock your world" was all for show. And I don't think Holly wanting to be in Playboy had any effect on his attitude towards her.

Chrissy gal

"Never underestimate the potential psychosis of a reality show contestant." managerr

LAST EDITED ON 09-05-03 AT 12:53 PM (EST)

Scott's "taste in women" may be anything but. I seem to recall some threads wondering out loud about Scott's orientation.

Scott is one very quiet dude. Almost too quiet. Zombie-like.

Contradictions don't exist. If you are faced with a contradiction, check your premises. You will find that one of them is wrong. -- Ayn Rand, Atlas Shrugged

I think he goes both ways. I think Tom might, too.

Maybe Smokey goes both ways too?

I Think that Holly just voted Herself out
The next show one of the girls are going.
The girls are going to have to pick the guys and i think that Melanie anh Holly are going to both pick Scott, and Scott is Going to pick Melanie.