Found this on MJ's AI blog--here is link to her blog...

http://mjsbigblog.com/categories/americanIdol/

scroll down to the KFOX section to get vid clip link to judge's comments on the finale and on Kat's saying the judges have been too hard on her (there are two clips). Snarky Simon is at it again! Randy is there with him. "We're what on the show? Uh, judges?!"

I think Simon was banking on Chris for the win...so the gloves are off now. When at this stage in the other 4 seasons did he talk sarcastically about the F2?