URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID44
Thread Number: 1874
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by Snidget on 04-19-06 at 08:02 AM
Step right up and tell us who you think America Should have voted out and who you think they will vote out.
Table of contents
Messages in this discussion
"Dial Idol Stats."
Posted by Snidget on 04-19-06 at 08:07 AM
Busy Signal Info:

Idol Busy Percent

Taylor Hicks 76.969 -
Elliott Yamin 74.236 -
Kellie Pickler 66.802 -
Katharine McPhee 63.957 -
Chris Daughtry 62.967 -
Paris Bennett 57.36 -
Ace Young 48.088 -


DialIdol
Rank

Idol DialIdol Score Margin Of Error

1-3 Taylor Hicks 30.774 1.574 -
1-3 Elliott Yamin 30.29 1.579 -
1-3 Katharine McPhee 27.763 1.608 -
4-6 Kellie Pickler 27.188 1.614 -
4-6 Chris Daughtry 25.409 1.634 -
4-6 Paris Bennett 24.376 1.645 -
7 Ace Young 20.5 1.687

Raw Data

Idol Busy Signals Votes Totals

Katharine McPhee 48375 27262 75637
Taylor Hicks 44690 13372 58062
Elliott Yamin 41976 14568 56544
Chris Daughtry 32287 18989 51276
Paris Bennett 19315 14358 33673
Kellie Pickler 21422 10646 32068
Ace Young 14764 15938 30702
Totals 222829 115133 337962


"RE: Dial Idol Stats."
Posted by Glow on 04-19-06 at 10:00 AM
hmm. Based on these (which I don't believe to be fullproof anyway), it looks like Kellie or Chris will fall into the bottom 3. Elliot looks very much safe all around (gained LOTS of Bucky votes). I don't think they'll put (let us know that Chris was in the bottom 3 - dammit I have to start voting again) Chris in the bottom 3 just yet so our big "surprise" (so very not surprised) in the bottom 3 will most likely be Kellie.

Doesn't matter though. Ace probably already has his bags packed. Going out on a high note, pretty boy. Good job.


an arkie work of art

"RE: Dial Idol Stats."
Posted by Magnolia_Rocker on 04-19-06 at 10:09 AM
I so hope you are right Glow. I would dearly love to see Kellie at least in the bottom three.


Siggy thanks to Syren!

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by CattyChat on 04-19-06 at 08:16 AM
LAST EDITED ON 04-19-06 AT 08:56 AM (EST)

I'm doing this in 3 phases, since we're getting down to the wire.

Should be Bottom 3 Based SOLELY on Last Night's Performance
Kellie ~~ Ace ~~ Elliott ~~~ Kellie to go

Should be Bottom 3 Overall Performances**
(**ETA This is Overall Talent including X-factor/Charisma)
Ace ~~ Paris ~~ Elliott ~~~ Ace to go

Will be Bottom 3
Ace ~~ Elliott ~~ Paris/Katharine ~~~ Elliott to go.


Kind Creation of ARNutz

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by Glow on 04-19-06 at 08:21 AM
I'll do three like CC did.

Overall Should:
Ace, Kellie, Elliot
Boot - Kellie

Based on last night only:
Kellie, Taylor, Elliot
Boot - Kellie

Will:
Ace, Elliot, Paris
Boot - Ace


an arkie work of art

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by Magnolia_Rocker on 04-19-06 at 08:32 AM
LAST EDITED ON 04-19-06 AT 08:36 AM (EST)

Following the format from above:

Based on last night:
Kellie, Ace, Elliott
Boot: Kellie

Overall Should:
Kellie, Ace, Paris
Boot: Kellie

Overall Will:
Ace, Elliott, Chris (I'm predicting a surprise in the bottom 3)
Boot: Ace


Siggy thanks to Syren!

Edit: Changed my surprise bottom pick to Chris

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by halfpintlemon on 04-19-06 at 09:10 PM
My thoughts exactly.
"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by mrc on 04-19-06 at 08:43 AM
Bottom three:
Ace, Elliott, Kellie (I hope)

Will go:
Ace


"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by geg6 on 04-19-06 at 08:52 AM
I'll follow the leader here:

Should go based on last night:
Bottom three: Kellie, Ace, Paris
Boot: Kellie

Should go based on overall performances:
Bottom three: Kellie, Ace, Paris
Boot: Paris

Will go:
Bottom three: Ace, Elliott, Paris
Boot: Elliott


Goddess of the Steeler Nation

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by geekboy on 04-19-06 at 09:31 AM
Bottom 3
=-=-=-=-

Should be: Paris/Ace/Kellie
Will be: Paris/Ace/Elliot

Bootee
=-=-=-

Should be: Kellie
Will be: Ace


geekboy

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by PagongRatEater on 04-19-06 at 09:35 AM
Keeping up with the lemmings.

Overall Bottom Three -
Ace, Paris, Elliott

Last Night Bottom Three -
Kellie, Ace, Elliott

Boot -
Elliott

I just think after Ace's close call last week, his fans might step up this week and save him for one more week.


But, the four of us had a great time.


"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by prosecutor on 04-19-06 at 09:43 AM
since pretty boy Ace and "dumb blonde" Kellie
aint goin nowhere here are my predictions

Should be: Ace,Kellie,Elliot
Will Be: Elliot, Paris, Kellie

Gone: Elliot will be gone tonite mainly
because he's no pretty boy like you know who
and based on Simon's comment.

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by Devious Weasel on 04-19-06 at 09:46 AM
I like the format, so I’ll continue as well

Should – Last Night
Kellie, Taylor, Elliott – Boot: Taylor

Should – Overall
Kellie, Ace, Taylor: Boot Kellie

Will
Elliott, Ace, Paris: Boot Elliott



"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by geekboy on 04-19-06 at 10:42 AM
I simply can't agree with all of you people saying Elliot is going next.

Yeah, he's been in the bottom three, but damn the boy can sing and he has improved. I think last night was his best. I simply don't see him going before Ace, before Kellie, and even before Kat.

Of course, what do I know, but i got a feeling it will NOT be Elliot in teh bottom three this week.

geekboy

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by geg6 on 04-19-06 at 11:00 AM
Well, if you look at my post, you'll see that I don't have Elliott in either of my "Should" categories. But my "Will" predictions aren't necessarily based on my preference, but on what I think the unwashed hordes of the American public will do. And I just don't think they're in love with Elliott.


Goddess of the Steeler Nation

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by PagongRatEater on 04-19-06 at 11:02 AM
Frankly, there isn't that much to love. Yeah, he can sing but he has no 'hook' and commands no specific audience.


But, the four of us had a great time.


"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by Devious Weasel on 04-19-06 at 11:59 AM
I'm in the same boat as Geg - I don't think he should go, don't think he deserves to go, but he and Ace are the two who have floated around the boot spot the most. The only thing in Elliott's favor for staying is Simon telling him he was in trouble - that always pumps up the vote.


"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by tamarama on 04-19-06 at 01:10 PM
>>The only thing in Elliott's favor for staying is Simon telling him he was in trouble - that always pumps up the vote.<<

That & I'm kinda hoping the family video last Wednesday has given him a little more "story."

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by emydi on 04-19-06 at 06:37 PM
I like this format too!!

I can't believe someone else thinks based on last nite, Taylor should be in bottom 3!!

Last nite Should be

Paris Kellie Taylor

Should go Kellie

Overall Should be

Ace Paris kellie

Should go Kellie

Will be

Paris Elliott Kellie

To go: Elliott



"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by nailbone on 04-19-06 at 11:08 AM
LAST EDITED ON 04-19-06 AT 12:07 PM (EST)

Last night's should:

Ace, Paris, Kellie
Boot - Kellie

Overall should:
Ace, Paris, Elliot
Boot - Ace

Will:
Ace, Paris, Elliot
Boot - Ace

ET: change my "boot"


Sig by Arkie!!

Holey carp! My blog! MySpace!
Official OT Tassel Adjuster o-
"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by nailbone on 04-20-06 at 02:36 PM
Should have gone with my original instinct of Chris as the surprise pick for the bottom 3.


Sig by Arkie!!
Holey carp! My blog! MySpace!
Official OT Tassel Adjuster o-
"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by theking0075 on 04-19-06 at 11:28 AM
This Week Only

Kellie, Elliot Katherine
Boot: Kellie

Overall
Elliot, Ace, Katherine
Boot: Elliot

Will Be
Elliot, Ace, Kellie
Boot: Kellie, in a shocker!

"Evil" Dr. Will: Reality Show Legend!

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by nailbone on 04-19-06 at 11:30 AM
Will Be
Elliot, Ace, Kellie
Boot: Kellie, in a shocker!

And if that happens, we will DEFINITELY get the Seacrest "you have to vote" lecture.


Sig by Arkie!!
Holey carp! My blog! MySpace!
Official OT Tassel Adjuster o-

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by geekboy on 04-19-06 at 11:35 AM
This would accomplish many things

1 - would make me happy
2 - would renew my faith in the American voting public
3 - would shock the H*LL out of me

i will believe it when it happens. I don't think it will happen until the final 3.

geekboy

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by Iconoclastic on 04-19-06 at 01:01 PM
This week should:
Kellie Ace Paris
Boot: Kellie

Overall should:
Kellie Ace Paris
Boot: Ace

Will:
Kellie Ace Paris
Boot: Ace

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by priestdi on 04-19-06 at 01:09 PM
Overall should:

Ace, Elliott, Kat (gasp)


This week should:

Ace, Kellie, Elliott


Actual bottom three:

Ace, Elliott ... and I have no idea, lol. I thought Paris was the best last night, but that doesn't always mean diddly. I guess Paris.


Gone:

I was assuming it's Elliott, until I saw the busy-stats. How very weird. That's still my guess, but it sure looks like he's safe.

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by nailbone on 04-19-06 at 01:20 PM
Overall should:
Ace, Elliott, Kat (gasp)

OK, you are SO on my list!!




Sig by Arkie!!
Holey carp! My blog! MySpace!
Official OT Tassel Adjuster o-

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by tamarama on 04-19-06 at 01:14 PM
I'll Play:

Last Night:
Kellie, Chris, Ace
Go: Kellie

Overall:
Ace, Kellie, Paris
Go: Ace

Will be:
Ace, Paris, Kellie/Chris
Go: Ace

(I agree it's time for a shocker, but not a boot shocker)

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by KingJames on 04-19-06 at 01:38 PM
FUN GAME...
LAST NIGHT:
KELLIE, ACE, CRIS

OVERALL
KELLIE, ACE, KELLIE
YES, I PUT KELLIE TWICE, FOR ALL THE TIMES SHE SHOULD HAVE GONE & DIDN'T

WILL:

ACE
BUT I HAVE BEEN WRONG A LOT. I STILL CAN'T BELIEVE MANDISA GOT VOTED OUT BEFORE PICKLES...JUST GOING ON TALENT

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by Bravegirl on 04-19-06 at 01:56 PM
"I was assuming it's Elliott, until I saw the busy-stats. How very weird. That's still my guess, but it sure looks like he's safe."


Where do you get that info from???

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by priestdi on 04-19-06 at 02:03 PM
http://dialidol.com/asp/predictions/Predictions.asp
"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by DontGetMeStarted on 04-19-06 at 03:14 PM
should go Kelli
will go Elliot
"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by prosecutor on 04-19-06 at 03:35 PM
The reason I picked Elliott to go is that
pretty boy sure looked extra pretty last
nite hahaha! soooo teenyboppers are gonna
vote like mad to keep him safe even if
he lands in the bottom 3. But Elliott based
on what Simon said is no pretty boy soooo
even though he is a waaaay better singer
than pretty boy Ace I predict that
he will not get the popular vote.
I hope I'm wrong and pretty boy goes home
tonite, but I highly doubt it.
"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by jen71 on 04-19-06 at 06:42 PM
Should be Bottom 3 Based SOLELY on Last Night's Performance
Kellie should go as she was the worst by far
Paris
Ace

Should be Bottom 3 Overall Performances
Kellie should go as she is definitely the worst by far
Paris
tied Elliott - sounds really good most of the time, but is a little bit boring
and Ace - seems very personable, but doesn't always sound the best

Will be Bottom 3
Ace will go since he doesn't appear to have many fans and he's been in danger of going more often than not
Paris
Chris/Kellie - shocking to find either here, but unless he's/she's too much the producers' favorite that they won't allow him/her to be here, I think he/she could be bottom 3, first to be safe from the boot

as a final thought, I think the final 2 will be Taylor and the horribly untalented and idiotic Kellie

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by Reality_Tv_fan_90 on 04-19-06 at 06:57 PM
Should Be
Bottom Three:
Ace, Elliot, Chris

Eliminated:
Ace

Will Be
Bottom Three:
Paris, Ace, Kellie

Eliminated:
Kellie


Scott

"RE: Should Go/Will Go. Rod Steward Edition"
Posted by xwraith27 on 04-19-06 at 07:53 PM
Based on last night alone...

Should:
Paris, Kellie, Ace - Kellie going

Would:
Elliott, Ace, Paris - Ace going