URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID88
Thread Number: 175
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by LaLaLisa on 09-13-05 at 06:02 PM
I think it has to be Suzie. I really thought she would stay because they love her voice and would want a woman in the final 3 but she's been in the bottom 3 more than anyone and they'd have a hard time explaining that. Plus, they have said repeatedly they need to listen to the fans.

On the other hand, Bottom 3 to Final 3 would make a good story...

Nah, I'm sticking with Suzie is out.

Table of contents
Messages in this discussion
"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by shanana banana on 09-13-05 at 06:07 PM
LAST EDITED ON 09-13-05 AT 06:08 PM (EST)

It should be Susie, but I'm betting they won't boot the final woman from the finale because of why.......RATINGS!!!

lol. So I'm going for Marty or MiG.

I'm pretty much resigned to the fact that JD is probably going to be the chosen one.

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by LaLaLisa on 09-13-05 at 06:17 PM
"It should be Susie, but I'm betting they won't boot the final woman from the finale because of why.......RATINGS!!!"

I was thinking that, too, but if she doesn't get the votes do you think she'll bring in the ratings?

Or is it just the possibility it might be a woman?

I just don't see how MiG is gonna wind up in the bottom 3 and I don't see them getting rid of Marty or JD.

Now that I think about it - I'll be surprised no matter who it is.

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by weltek on 09-13-05 at 07:19 PM

WEll, the editing has kept us guessing, that's for sure. Given the editing, pretty sure it will be Suzie or Mig. I'm saying Suzie will go. Why? Because a finale of the other three is better than one with Suzie in it. So speaking of ratings...

Plus, Mig obviously has a HUGE loyal fan base. Why alienate them?


"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by Glow on 09-14-05 at 08:11 AM
I agree with Weltek.


"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by pinay_racer on 09-13-05 at 11:01 PM
they wouldnt vote out suzie because they wouldnt remove the last woman. it wouldnt look good for inxs if they do this.

they wouldnt cut JD because he creates controversy. inxs needs a guy like him in the final 3. JD is the guy everyone hates.

so it's down to either mig and marty.

since i love Mig-marty has to go.

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by Wacko Jacko on 09-13-05 at 11:24 PM
Should be MiG or Suzie. Either one..Marty and JD are obvisiously the two best. I like Suzie more than MiG, but Mig better for InXs. So either of those.
"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by okaychatt on 09-14-05 at 00:07 AM
I thought Mig's performance was the weakest tonight, but that doesn't mean he'll be the one to go.

He just doesn't seem to connect to the fans the way the other three do.

For me, he has the dullest personality of all of the F4.


Everyone is entitled to my opinion.

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by triednottowatch on 09-14-05 at 00:21 AM
Okay, I'm sure it was explained and I just missed it somewhere, but............how does tomorrow work? Does the person receiving the least amount of votes get eliminated? Then the top three sing an INXS song? Or do the bottom three perform and the top vote-getter sits it out? Then they eliminate Suzie?

After all this time, I find it hard to believe they would put the person they are leaning toward at the mercy of the voting public. Up to this point INXS has still been in control of who they sent home.

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by cycles2k on 09-14-05 at 02:33 AM
My predictions have been wrong for the past two weeks, so I offer them with the warning that they are almost certainly wrong but....

My guess is for Suzie to go home next. She is likable but her performance was not inspiring. It was good but not great.

I predict a Mig or JD win. I enjoyed Paint It Black and think Mig would be just as good as or better than JD for INXS.

Marty is great. He is just not INXS.

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by Shypappy on 09-14-05 at 10:24 AM
LAST EDITED ON 09-14-05 AT 10:25 AM (EST)

Suzie may not have had her best night with Interstate love song, but she's been so good throuout this competition, I think it's forgivable. She still has the best voice in the competition!

Marty should go! They act all cool about it, but I'll bet INXS didn't like his little record executive style pitch during the interviews. What a cocky little bastage!

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by trigirl on 09-14-05 at 10:52 AM
This is going to be the toughest night for sure. I wonder if they will make all four sing INXS songs, but tell us that the top vote getter is safe anyway. They have to hear MiG sing an INXS song. We should get to hear MiG sing an INXS song!

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by Tahj on 09-14-05 at 11:33 AM
I think it will be Suzie too. Those guys can't handle a woman!


Moves courtesy of Syren

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by triednottowatch on 09-14-05 at 04:45 PM
Dave acts like he would like to "handle" her. Carmen has probably gotten jealous by now.
"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by freefromwhatyouare on 09-14-05 at 05:41 PM
Hi All!

Tonight's elimination is the last before the sunglass wearing, washed up crew picks a vocalist...and do you really think the singer they pick will last longer than the upcoming album and tour? No...and I think this will be last we hear of INXS also. Michael wrote great songs and Andrew the lead writer now, just isn't the same without him.

Ok, on who's going home tonight:

Suzie is the weakest left of what I feel are 4 very marginal talents. I do like Marty's presence and really feel he is the only true musician on this show.

Suzie tonight will once again show her vocal limitations..and her lame, fake, "Rock Star" wanna be stage antics. She was kept around as the token female, but now for the finale they will prefer the fight between the boyz...INXS talked of prefering a female early on, but Suzie 'aint it.

So yes, Suzie leaves tonight and she will break down in tears and the producers will soil themselves trying to get shots of her and the sunglass crew acting depressed.

Marty should win this thing, but as has been said her many times...he will be better off on his own or with his band.

I was also thinking maybe Suzie and Mig will both go down tonight so they can have a battle royale next week between Marty and J.D. Each doing at least 3 songs to really show how much more talent Marty has than J.D. Then INXS picks J.D. and we never hear from them again...

Why isn't the finale 2 hours? Come on CBS you have been trying to kill this show from the start. Cutting out the Monday show for re-runs of "2 losers and a fat ugly kid" Now that the ratings are up you need to make the finale a 2 hour ratings booster.

Bye Bye Suzie..good luck to you on open mike night at your local pub...

Peace and Love!

Michael..

P.S. Note to Dave...Call Perry and get the band back together...the ##### your putting out now just is filler...Jane's makes the world go 'round..

Or else Perry may call CBS for the next series..."Janes Addiction Axe Man Search"

"RE: Who won't make it to the final three?"
Posted by Melody on 09-15-05 at 10:08 PM
FreeFromWhatYouAre excellent post. Finally, someone who articulates the truth ---- Marty is the only true musician in the group. J.D. is very sincere, but he always seems like he is posing....and I just can't get past his low notes which all sound like Elvis.

J.D. was ordinary with "Pretty Vegas" on acoustic guitar. Marty was interesting (not perfect) and unique when he did "Trees" on acoustic guitar. When you put J.D. and Marty side by side J.D.'s limitations are definitely illuminated.