URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID51
Thread Number: 160
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"lcs1 vs. lcs2, no contest"
Posted by newsomewayne on 08-06-04 at 08:10 AM
So lcs 3 is going to be 1st season vs. 2nd season, huh? Personally, I think it's no contest. As a group, the 1st season's cast is a hundred times funnier than this season's. Of course there are notable exceptions such as Not Phun and spiky-haired chick from lcs1 and John and Alonzo from lcs 2. Switch them and lcs 1 would have no problem going 10-0 vs. lcs 2. Anyody agree?

By the way, did I catch a little edited foreshadowing a couple of weeks ago. I seem to recall Alonzo saying, "I'll take on anybody. I'd challenge Ralphie May." That match-up would ROCK!

Table of contents
Messages in this discussion
"RE: lcs1 vs. lcs2, no contest"
Posted by Oscirus on 08-06-04 at 08:48 AM
LAST EDITED ON 08-06-04 AT 11:20 AM (EST)

Lc1's bottom two was rather weak. The Lcs2 women could beat the lcs1's women easily. Ics2's top 2 would take last comic standing's top 2. so I'd doubt it would be the massacre that you speak of.


"RE: lcs1 vs. lcs2, no contest"
Posted by theking0075 on 08-06-04 at 09:15 AM
>Ic1's bottom two was rather weak
>The ic2 women could beat
>the ic1's women easily. Ic2's
>top 2 would take last
>comic standing's top 2. so
>I'd doubt it would be
>the massacre that you speak
>of.
>

Yep, the way you lay it out it looks like LCS 1 would win 6-4, but one great performance from Jay London or Todd Glass and suddenly is 5-5. It think it wold be tight!


"Evil" Dr. Will: Reality Show Legend!

"RE: lcs1 vs. lcs2, no contest"
Posted by Oscirus on 08-06-04 at 11:19 AM
I think I said it wrong but the way I meant it it would be 6-4 in favor of Lcs2.

Lcs2 women over the lcs1 women-+3
Lcs top 2 over lcs1 top2 -+2
Lcs 2's bottom2 over Lcs1's -+1 (bonnie+ spike haired chick were in the bottom 2 also)

"RE: lcs1 vs. lcs2, no contest"
Posted by shaw86 on 08-06-04 at 02:41 PM
if they do the challenges by how got eliminated where(like 10th vs. 10th)then the match-ups would be
10th sean kent vs. bonnie macfarland - kent would win
9th terie joyce vs. todd glass - glass would win
8th rob cantrell vs. ant - i hope cantrell
7th dave mordall vs. jay london - good matchup
6th geoff brown vs. corey holcomb - brown wins
5th tess vs. i think tammy? - there both terrible
4th corey kahany vs. kathleen madigan- evenly mached
3rd rich vos vs. we don know yet
2nd ralphie may vs. we don know yet
1st dat phan vs. we don know yet

i think ralphie and rich could beat any of the final 3 this year on pure standup but i dont know if dat could

"RE: lcs1 vs. lcs2, no contest"
Posted by LeftPinky on 08-06-04 at 04:13 PM
Using your list...
10. Kent wins - easily...
9. Glass wins - easily...
8. Ant in a squeaker
7. Dave Mordal - hands down!
6. toss-up
5. toss-up
4. Kahany - a squeaker
3. Should be Vos vs. Gulman - Vos wins
2. should be May vs. Heffron - good match-up
1. Should be Phan vs. Bodden - Bodden hands down!

My numbers say LCS1 4, LCS2 3 - to close to call 3.

The only truly terrible one of the top 7 in either show was Dat Phan. Perhaps LCS1 will swap him with Buck Star.
Slice & Dice Chop Shop 2004

"RE: lcs1 vs. lcs2, no contest"
Posted by newsomewayne on 08-09-04 at 12:33 PM
Okay, so maybe I was a reaching a little when I said lcs1 would win 10-0, but that was with my presumption of switching Alonzo and John with Tere and Dat.

It probably will be a matchup in order of elimination from each show, but if I was producing it, I would try to match up by complementing styles or comedic ability. Of course if the producers were actually capable of judging comedic ability, half the contestants wouldn't even be on the show. But I digress...

My matchups - in no particular order - would be...

Todd Glass vs. Rob Cantrell; both very goofy: toss-up with edge to Todd for experience.

Bonnie vs. Tere Joyce; edgy female humour: winner-Bonnie, she has great timing

Ant vs. Sean; don't remember Sean much, but Ant has too much set-up for too little punchline: winner Sean

Tammy vs. Corey Kahaney; Italian jokes vs. divorcee jokes: toss-up with no edge to either player.

John Heffron vs. Ralphie May; manic childhood ranting vs. loud ranting about adult inconveniences: both are great, but winner - Ralphie May

Jay London vs. Dat Phan; less talking, but several laughs vs. LOTS of babbling with few laughs: winner - Jay London

Corey vs. Geoff Brown; new black material that needs development vs. old black material that needs a new audience: winner - Geoff Brown.

Alonzo Bodden vs. Rich Voss; both are just plain funny; I prefer Rich, but this must be considered a toss-up.

Kathleen Madigan vs. Dave Mordal; Kathleen has more experience, but I think Dave appeals to more people and has funnier material; winner - Dave Mordal.

Gary Gullman vs. Tess; two leftovers from previous 9 matchups; toss-up with edge to Gulman for his charm and clean-cut look.

My assessment gives me LCS1 4 wins vs. LCS2 2 wins with 4 tossups. Splitting those would give me 6-4 for LCS 1. While not the slam dunk I said it would be before, I still think lcs1 as a group is hands down funnnier.

"RE: lcs1 vs. lcs2, no contest"
Posted by ejm92 on 08-09-04 at 12:38 PM
I think it depends how they do the matchups....and the voting might be slightly skewed since some people may not have seen the first season and they might be partial to the second season's comedians....personally I think season 2 would win 6-4.


Packers '04: "It's Either Super Bowl Or Bust" - Brett Favre
"RE: lcs1 vs. lcs2, no contest"
Posted by shaw86 on 08-10-04 at 11:45 PM
i just watched a tape i had from season one from the vegas finals and saw tere sean ralphie and dat perform so...
tere wasnt really that funny
sean had some texas being racist jokes
ralphie looking back was hilarious with jokes bout goin to india
dat was ok