#5 Boston Rob.
#14 Kim SpradlinRob was always more entertaining than Tom.
Kim won Survivor. I don't know what Cook Island was but it wasn't Survivor since people were more interested in representing their race than playing the game. With that overpowered idol Yul was never in danger of being voted out and had a limo drive to the F3.
#8 Tom Westman
#14 Kim Spradlin
It took Rob 4 chances to get it right. My guess is if ANYONE had 4 chances they'd most likely win too. Yes, even RussHell. Perhaps even NaOnka.
Yul was blessed with a VERY lucky idol, and with 2 peeps who wanted to mutiny their own tribemates. His way was practically paved and all he had to do was walk there.
Russell would be 0 for 1000! Rupert, Colby, Jerri, Steph, James, Amanda and Coach are all 0 for 3 and none is likely to win.
(You could add Cirie but she should be 2 for 3 and Parvati should be the one who is 0 for 3!)
I can't really argue against Tom though but, like Rob, he is 1/2 making the finale and 1/2 getting voted out before jury. I could say that Rob has a better record (3 for 4) making the merge.