URL: http://community.realitytvworld.com/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/rtvw2/community/dcboard.cgi
Forum: DCForumID44
Thread Number: 1455
[ Go back to previous page ]
Original Message
"American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by seahorse on 05-04-05 at 08:35 PM
Let's discuss tonight's final 5 results show here only until 12:00 EST
Table of contents
Messages in this discussion
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by seahorse on 05-04-05 at 09:00 PM
Why are they singing a song so closely related to Clay Aiken?
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by kathliam on 05-04-05 at 09:02 PM
It's Bo's now. Quick, someone get Glow a cool rag.
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by LibraRising on 05-04-05 at 09:03 PM
And they don't even mention him, but mention Michael W. Smith?
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by Spidey on 05-04-05 at 09:14 PM
Clay did a MUCH better job on this song.

Anthony and Carrie together, in particular, were horrific.

"Agree"
Posted by Breezy on 05-05-05 at 08:21 AM
They need to ban that song from being song on AI. Noone will ever be able to top Clay's rendition.

Carrie, Vonzel and Anthony need to learn how to harmonize. That was awful!

"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by LibraRising on 05-04-05 at 09:02 PM
Two fashion comments off the bat:

Bo has goofy sunglasses again.
And Scott's stylist that he mentioned last night? Needs to pick out clothes that do not accent his hairy chest.

That is all.

"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by seahorse on 05-04-05 at 09:04 PM
Randy and Simon get flowers but not Paula, wtf.

"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by zazzy on 05-04-05 at 09:11 PM
They said "they are for you Paula"--so both bouquets were for Paula--it was easier to hand them to either side, perhaps?
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by seahorse on 05-04-05 at 09:13 PM
She needs them for sure tonight.
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by seahorse on 05-04-05 at 09:07 PM
I wonder if Paula is going to watch her special tonight on ABC. Will there be anything new not previously let out.
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by seahorse on 05-04-05 at 09:09 PM
Anthony on the coach, Vonzell on the floor, Scott on the coach. Bo on the floor
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by seahorse on 05-04-05 at 09:11 PM
Bo, Vonzell, and Carrie are the top 3. When Bo was left standing it became obvious that the two sitting down were in trouble, Scott and Anthony.
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by Spidey on 05-04-05 at 09:12 PM
LAST EDITED ON 05-04-05 AT 09:17 PM (EST)

From the second RYan told Anthony to sit on the couch, it was totally obvious what they were doing. You could even hear Anthony say "It isn't over."

Stupid.

*etr sigpic

"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by Snidget on 05-04-05 at 09:14 PM
I think Scott got too cocky.

The producers are sometimes take their role of doling out the Karma just a little too seriously.

The universe always messes with you when you get too cocky.

"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by seahorse on 05-04-05 at 09:14 PM
Especially when the word safe was not used.
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by Spidey on 05-04-05 at 09:23 PM
Bingo. It's the equivalent of Phil saying "You are the first team to arrive ..."
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by skye on 05-04-05 at 09:14 PM
I just dispise when Seacrest pulls that sophmoric crap but at least we have the right bottom two tonight.

"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by seahorse on 05-04-05 at 09:16 PM
It is to be expected from this show.
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by zazzy on 05-04-05 at 09:14 PM
Anthony siad "it's not over" as he headed toward the couch. I think he knows what was on the idolonfox site before the show.
"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by bostonrobfan on 05-04-05 at 11:44 PM
What was on the site? ITA, I figured as soon as they sent A-Fed to the couch that was where the possible bootees would be.
"Hooray!"
Posted by LibraRising on 05-04-05 at 09:25 PM
Scott's gone! Happy dance, happy dance.
"RE: Hooray!"
Posted by cjhope117 on 05-04-05 at 09:33 PM
Its about f-ing time. Even though Anthony totally blew last night's performance I was totally ready for Scott to go.
"RE: Hooray!"
Posted by bostonrobfan on 05-04-05 at 11:41 PM
I jumped up off the couch, cheering like crazy. Woohoo!!!!! Yay!!!
"Scott goes home"
Posted by Snidget on 05-04-05 at 09:29 PM
Doing the happy dance.

Woulda been sad for Anthony to go home on his B-day.

"RE: Scott goes home"
Posted by Spidey on 05-04-05 at 09:32 PM
I am particualrly enjoying the irony of the song Scott sang before he got the boot.

Now he needs to go away for good.

"He will"
Posted by Breezy on 05-05-05 at 08:24 AM
I really don't see how he could be marketable. Nice voice yes, but the rest of the package is lacking big time. IMHO
"RE: He will"
Posted by okaychatt on 05-07-05 at 07:11 PM
<rest of the package is lacking big time.

Yep. Scott always seemed so wrapped up in himself that he forgot to interact with the audience. He played the audience. He may have even sung to the audience.

But he never, ever, seemed to LIKE the audience.


Everyone is entitled to my opinion.

"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by Bebo on 05-04-05 at 10:30 PM
Turned on just in time to see the bottom 2, and was in a good enough mood about it to keep watching. I'm glad Anthony didn't have to go home on his birthday - that would have sucked.

And now Scott has plenty of time to figure out what he's singing next week, and I know for a fact that next week's summary writer is thrilled she won't have to be listening to it.


"If there was ever a time you wanted permission to run over a clown . . . ."

"RE: American Idol Final 5 Results Show East Coast Thread "
Posted by Glow on 05-05-05 at 07:54 AM
ohmigawd Bo makes me swoony. He sounded wonderful.

Please forgive me for saying this, but I felt bad for Scott. I think he sounded really good this week and I didn't want to see him get booted on his best week. Did I vote for him? Well, no. Was he one of my favorites through the season? No. Did I think he would win? No. That's not the point. When they were watching his "journey" and he was biting his bottom lip, I said to DF, "awww. He's going to cry." I, of course, got an eye roll for saying that. Oh well. I felt bad. *shrug*

Anthony should have gone last night. And Vonzell should have been on the couch beside him.


"I Agree"
Posted by samboohoo on 05-05-05 at 08:31 AM
with the part about Bo making you swoony.


Icey bounced my Dicey

Okay, maybe I agree about Vonzell and Anthony too, but there wasn't any part of me feeling sorry for Scott.


"RE: I Agree"
Posted by okaychatt on 05-07-05 at 07:14 PM
<but there wasn't any part of me feeling sorry for Scott.

Me either. I'd bet the guys he sang with during the auditions were jumping for joy with the rest of us.

What an a$$ Scott was during that whole time, refusing to show up for rehearsal, acting as if he were All That.

Couldn't stand him then, and my opinion has gone downhill ever since.

Was anyone on the set sad to see him go? Not that I recall.

LOSER!!!


Everyone is entitled to my opinion.