John remids me of that frog from the old Warner Bros. cartoons, who does nothing but sit and croak, and then when no one's looking, he springs to life and sings and dances. John gets on stage and I'm thinking, "Whoa! Where did THAT come from?!"

Diz

OMG...LMAO!

*Courtesy of IceCat*

I'm actually pretty pleased with the final 5, they are who I would have picked. However, I would have liked to see Kathleen go up since she was the only one who hadn't and it's kind of hard to judge how well she'd do in a head-to-head otherwise. Still, she doesn't irritate me the way some of the already-gone ones did.

I am SO GLAD Corey got taken out! Who was he kidding when he thought he was one of the "heavyweights" unless he was referring to his actual weight? Alonzo and John just blew him out of the water. He wasn't even mildly humorous to me.

Right now I'm leaning for either a John or Alonzo win. I really can't see any of the others coming that close. John just has this maniacal energy about him and Alonzo is just flat out funny. I still like Tammy, but I don't see her winning.

I have never liked Corey, Tammy, or Kathleen. I hope John, Alonzo, or Gary wins. I missed last nights episode but I have it on tape. Thats my opinion.

I watch Big Brother when there is "nothing else on".

John, John, and John. That's who I am voting for. He had me ROLLING last night. I love is sets. He cracks me up. Alonzo is a funny guy too. He is really good at what he does. And I'm glad they picked him as the third comedian, though I would rather have seen Kathleen. Corey was somewhat funny last night, but couldn't hold a candle to the other two. I was kind of surprised that Alonzo beat John honestly.

I hope Tammy comes in last. I just don't think she is funny. She won immunity based on her looks only. The God-daughter? Come on. How over used is that!

Gary and Kathleen are funny people, but I don't think they will win. Gary has definitely proven himself (what has Kathleen done on this show?), but he is kind of inconsistent. John and Alonzo have been consistently funny, so I would love to see them as the final 2.

JayMo was actually kind of funny last night.

Snazzy new sigpic by Slice
Survivor All Stars PTB Champ!

LAST EDITED ON 07-21-04 AT 06:12 PM (EST)

I agree with everything you said.

"I hope Tammy comes in last. I just don't think she is funny. She won immunity based on her looks only. The God-daughter? Come on. How over used is that!"

So true. John is also my very favorite. Gary of course is my eye candy.

*Courtesy of IceCat*

At this point I have no idea if Kathleen is funny or not. I don't remember. I wanted to see her in the head-to-head so I would know how she performs. She must be a nice person because she loves the dog. (I'm a dog person) But that doesn't mean she is funny on stage.

I think they told the focus group we want a female to win this. It was like they thought Tammy was hot and cute so they picked her. And then they picked Kathleen next. All the guys were at the bottom.

My choice for funniest has been Alonzo and I still think he should win. But I do enjoy John too, so it wouldn't bother me if he won either. Gary is okay. I liked Tammy at first but have become bored with her. And I don't remember what Kathleen does that is funny. And I won't miss Corey. He was starting to annoy me with the same type of jokes over and over.

Hey everyone...first time poster, long time watcher of LCS.

I'm generally happy with the final 5 with the exception of Tammy. Never liked her from the start. I would LOVE it if John won, he cracks me up every time. Is it just me or did he seem really worried and nervous last night when it came down to either him or Corey? He shouldn't have been since Corey was absolutely awful. I think maybe he needs to have a little confidence. He and Alonzo are the funniest people there with Gary running a close third.

LAST EDITED ON 07-21-04 AT 03:05 PM (EST)

LAST EDITED ON 07-21-04 AT 03:04 PM (EST)

I’m slightly conflicted with who I want to win. It’s a rich assortment of comics we are dealing with here. We have the polarizing humour and race relations of Alonzo (who almost made me pis# my pants), or the vanilla flavour comedy of Gary ‘the Jew’ Gulman (I converted to Judaism when I was twenty, I may have to vote for him based only on religion, us Jews stick together). Kathleen is so now threatening that I can almost class her as a nonentity, she is giving me nothing here. I’ll just classify her as a possible sleeper. Tammy is hot, so she got that going for her, and I’m not concerning myself with the stupid reality drama she caused and I’m not factoring in her crappy comedy. I only concerned with her hot body and if I’m alone when I‘m watching the show, it’s a toss up. And John, he is a guy I can relate to. Even thou I was the middle child I still had a younger brother, and I too use to kiss ##### with those Christmas rapping tubs. So he has my attention with his youth based family dynamic material. And, if we factor in the wild card vote I’m living in a constant state of conflict.

i am definitely rooting for john, with alonzo in 2nd (but not a particularly close 2nd). i was laughing out loud at john's set last night. alonzo made me chuckle a little (but not as much as in some of his previous things). i never found corey funny, and i thought his performance was particularly bad.

i'll echo the sentiments above that gary has a few funny jokes and has his looks going for him. he needs to have new material.

and tammy DEFINITELY needs new stuff. you can only laugh at the pesci uncles so many times, ya know.

and kathleen... i don't remember her act at all, although the fact she hasn't been challenged yet make me think the other comedians must like/respect/fear her. so maybe she'll do well.

i predict:
5) tammy
4) gary
3) kathleen
2) alonzo
1) john

LAST EDITED ON 07-21-04 AT 05:12 PM (EST)

alonzo was by far the funniest, just as he has always been

corey was by far the unfunniest, just as he has always been <edit to add in my reaction last night on his elimination, although as soon as i saw the dynamic, i knew he'd be going> HELL YEAH! </edit>

john just seemed like he needed his meds. wrapping paper tube jokes = not funny, no matter how hyped up on crack you are while you're making them

Ranking them from best to worst:

1. John
2. Alonzo
3. Gary
4. Kathleen (simply because she hasn't been tested yet in this format)
5. Tammy

My prediction for who wins, though:

Gary.

He's the most likable. He's the one who's had the most air time. He's the one the at-home audience was rooting for. Dat Phan had reasons 2 & 3 going for him last season. Gary's following the same track, only he's a much better comedian.

Fester
If it's not Gary, it will be Alonzo. John is a darkhorse. Kathleen and Tammy have virtually no shot. Kathleen because she was MIA during the House period, and Tammy because she was shown as a manipulative bee-yotch.