She did get to sing the encore though.

Actually, I think her voice is much more in the range of Michael Hutchence's than MiG's is. He seems to not be able to hit the really low, growly notes like she can.

Have to agree with you there. I don't get the whole MiG thing. I find him to be the polar opposite of Michael Hutchence in every way. I will scratch INXS off my favorite bands list if they pick him. And that will kill me because I have an autographed "Kick" album cover in my office.

I'm such a slut for the blues.

I won't vote for her because no matter how hard she tries she is not good for the new lead singer of INXs. I established that really early in the process. I don't vote who is the best that week but who is the best fit for INXs. She is not a good fit.

I agree that she will not win but that is no reason not to vote for her each week. A woman is not going to be the next singer of INXS.

Every additional week that she is on the show is more exposure for her. INXS and Dave obviously think she has talent or they would not be pumping her up all of the time. I say vote for her and give her more face time.

I believe part of the problem with viewer voting is that Suzy is from Canada - half of their voting time is also the voting time for Canadian Idol. I know INXS is higher calibre but people who actually going to spend the time to vote are also the people who will vote for Canadian Idol contestants.

I think that anyone who wants a Canadian contestant to win will vote for JD - the only male Canadian. If a woman is not going to win, why vote for one.

I also beieve that the world will vote all the women in the bottom three and they will not survive the competition-so sad.

I like Susie-I have always liked her better than Jessica or Deanna. I also love what Jordis can do with a song. I am so glad that Deanna is gone. Her voice sounded like she tried to swallow, but it got stuck in there somewhere. Better voice for smokey blues bars than rock halls. Dave Navarro was too impressed with her, for sure (she's a tiny bunny with a big voice).

Jeez, I hope JD doesn't win.......

There isn't always a "good" reason not to care for someone as a performer. Suzie just annoys me for no specific reason. Her voice is good enough, she's cute enough, but when she got the encore, I said thank goodness for my dvr, so I can fast forward through this annoying faux rocker junk.

Deanna, on the other hand, I always liked, even though her performances didn't always cut it.

And the comment about Canadian voters may or may not be valid, because notice how one week, Deanna started out bottom 3 but was pulled out by later voters.

I really dig Suzie!

She blew it on night 1 when she messed the lyrics, but every performance since then has been just awesome!

Does a great job of the INXS tunes!

I found her a little too arrogant last night - how many times did she say she's in the "top one"???? We only saw two that they aired - I'm guessing she said it 50 more.

And I thought they said she was the only one who was never in the bottom three - not necessarily that she was the top vote getter. Sheesh! You'd think she would appreciate that she's still in a precarious position and not be so arrogant.

I feel the same way as most of the people who have commented on this thread. She is a good singer but compared to some of the others she just doesn't have that edge about her. I know after last night's show I am getting a little tired of her personality. I don't know if it is just a bitchy opinion on my part but it seems that she does a lot of whinning to get what she wants and then whins about if she is able to do it after she gets the song. Then the whole crying to Deanna and Mig in hopes that they would let her do her original song after it was her that came up with the whole pull your name from a hat idea, I was like c'mon woman if you wanted to do it so bad why not fight for it?

I think people are too hard on Suzie for her emotions!

I'll bet most of your favorite rockstars out there are pricks, or whiners, or whatever...you just don't see that cause they're not on a reality show.

She's got the best voice, she should be judged on that!

This is turning into the Susie show. It's like the girl with low self esteem that finally made the cheerleading squad. She's now so wrapped up in herself that is distracting.

It's all about me, me, me!

Everyone is hard on JD for his arrogance, why shouldn't we treat Suzie the same?

Oh I agree it is becoming the Suzie show. I am getting a little upset with her. She could have easily been sitting in 4th place all night during the voting. Which would have kept her out of the bottom 3. But it meant she did not end up in the top 3 either. But she is acting like she was voted in top spot. I am finding her personality grating. The crying and giggling. The look on JD's face when she collapsed into giggles at the outside table said it all. Good she got her one week out of the bottom 3. But I think she will be back in the bottom 3 this week. She just doesn't have the fans backing her. And I think she would be a boring pick for the winner. But INXS may want her so they can be in charge. I think more and more they want someone they can control like MiG or Suzie.

I agree with all of the above reasons about why Suzie is disliked so much. She IS arrogant......even though she has a very good voice, it is definitely not the best of the final 6. I love the comment about the soccer mom trying to be a rock n roller. Priceless! My main reason for not liking Suzie is that I just don't enjoy her performances. Even if she nails a song, her stage presence turns me off. Also, my dislike of her goes back to week one when she was nasty to Marty. Trying to psych him out before the competition by tell him that his raspy voice may be the result of polyps on his vocal cords. Mean girl!

I'm honestly excited to watch her do Bohemian Rhapsody tonight -- I think she's going be be amazing -- but for Suzie to front this band, I think she needs:

1) A total makeover into a fashion goddess -- that "soccer mom" comment was brilliant. The black hair dye/extensions aren't fooling anyone.

2) A stylist in her hip pocket

3) Serious dancing lessons so she can move with some sensuality

4) Some *action* -- perhaps would help with #3

5) More lean muscle

6) A stage name. "Suzie McNeil" is a lovely name, but it makes me think of a 25-year-old marketing manager sending out email campaigns, not a rock star.

Fortunately, none of those things are hard to come by in Hollywood!

IMO Suzie rocked tonite! A definite vote getter.

Suzie did an awesome job tonight! Took a difficult song and nailed it.

Signature Created By: tribephyl

Oh puhleeze! She hit the notes of an all-time great song! She added NOTHING to it. Her outfit - bad to the point of distraction. Her movements - eh. The choir was more rocking in that performance than she was.

Suzie's one of those rockers that can belt out a song at the drop of a hat but I don't get into watching her perform. Some of the earlier comments on this board about her persona were dead on. Her stage presence needs a step up big time.

Also, I thought she did BR okay last night, thanks to the awesome band ..they were superb! BUT, I did hear a few notes of uncertainty and some questionable lyric queues from her. The comment that it had been the "best" in the whole competition was a little over the top for me.

Funny, I totally forgot about her being the one that was talking to Marty about is voice in the first show. Diss on her for that....she could take a few lesson from him on stage presence.

Put Suzie on American Idol, and we'd all be raving about her. But on RSI, she doesn't shine. My simple opinion is this ... Suzie is not a rocker. Great voice, pretty girl ... but just not a rocker. Learning how to "rock" looks contrived and awkward - you either have it or don't. Suzie doesn't. She's in the wrong competition.

The thing about Suzie is she has grown more than anyone throughout this competition and she had the most to prove.

She has one of the best voices without a doubt.

I can see what people are saying about her stage presence but even that has improved throughout this competition.

It boggles my mind that some people making comments here don't see what an overall fantastic job she has done. Last night's performance was just incredible. Can anyone appreciate what a hard song that was to sing? She was spot on.

Moves courtesy of Syren

I've read all these posts and they still haven't changed my mind. Love Suzie!