Tonights show was so crazy like i didn't even understand what happened watever

• RE: I can't beleive the Ninja warrior was defeated,Colonel Zoidberg, 07:57 AM, 09-06-06
  • RE: I can't beleive the Ninja warrior was defeated,nazpink, 08:46 AM, 09-06-06

I was getting a Survivor: All Stars vibe out of this up until when Will and Boogie's plans unraveled. Basically, what happened tonight was what I wanted to happen on Survivor to Boston Rob. The part of Boston Rob is being played by Will, Amber is now Boogie, Janelle is the new annoying Jenna, and we have Erika as a less hairy version of Rupert. I saw Erika's efforts to get Will out as being on the same level as Rupert's efforts to toss Rob. It was a noble last-ditch effort, but it couldn't possibly work (though I suppose if Jenna won anything like the POV in Survivor, she might have considered it.) I thought Will had Janelle's trust, and she would vote out Erika because Erika was annoying, just like Jenna voted out Rupert to save her own skin from a possible purple rock.

Unfortunately, as far as entertainment goes, Erika is no Rupert. And like the last All-Stars, I don't care who wins as long as it's not Jenna...I mean Janelle.

My guess (and I don't have live feeds I had to watch the edited version) is that Janelle and Erika were only able to successfully compare notes due to the fact that Will told them the exact same thing in the exact same words in the exact same location. Otherwise, there may have still been a lingering doubt in Janelle's head to stop her from completely trusting Erika and voting out Will. In my opinion, that's where Will truly went wrong. It is pretty astonishing to see Will voted out though, but as far as I'm concerned he was still quite successful given the amount of time he stayed in the house and the target he had on his back.